When did biblical Semicha become extinct?[1]
The conventional approach is that it became extinct sometime within the Talmudic era due to government decrees which gave a penalty of death for those who gave Semicha.[2] However, the Rebbe explains, and proves, that in truth it only became completely extinct much later on in the times of the early Rishonim.[3] The Rebbe explains that while Biblical Semicha did become rare within the Talmudic era, nonetheless, it still existed as an anomaly up until the Rishonic period of the Rif.
[1] See Pesakim Uteshuvos 242:16; See regarding the general concept of Biblical Semicha: Sanhedrin 2b; Rambam Sanhedrin 4
[2] See Sanhedrin 14a [Five major Tanaim getting Semicha from Rav Yehuda Ben Bava]; Ramban Sefer Hamitzvos Asei 153 [Semicha ended with Rebbe Hillel son on Yehuda Nesia in year 4118, which is 357 ACE]; Sefer Hazechus on Rif Gittin 4; Tashbeitz in Zohar HaRakia 54; Chasam Sofer O.C. 203; Beis Efraim O.C. 51
[3] Rebbe in Toras Menachem 5745 1 p. 465-480 based on Ran, Ritva and Milchamos Hashem of Ramban Rosh Hashanha 4 that the Rif blew Shofar on Rosh Hashanah that fell on Shabbos;
Must the water in electric Shabbos urns be hot before the start of Shabbos? May one fill it with cold water anytime before Shekia?[1]
The water in electric Shabbos urns must be hot [at least Yad Soledes, 50 Celsius, 122 Fahrenheit] before the start of Shabbos. All water urns that have interchangeable modes of temperature, as do Shabbos mode urns which contain a Shabbos mode button, and as do all urns that contain a button to press in order to re-boil the water, are subject to the restrictions of Shehiya which prohibits one from leaving non-half cooked food on an open flame into Shabbos. Now, although in general one has the option of covering the heat source in order to permit leaving even raw food onto it into Shabbos for it to cook over Shabbos, this is not possible by a water urn, as nobody will place a cover within the urn over the heating element. Accordingly, the only option is to make sure that the water is at least half cooked before sunset, which requires one to place the water into the urn sometime before sunset, depending on the size of the urn and the temperature of the water.
[1] See Admur 254:14; Minchas Yitzchak 5:91; Igros Moshe 4:74; Inyanei Bishul 22; Shevet Halevi 5:30; Shabbos Kehalacha 8:6; Vol. 1 page 299; pages 315-319; SSH”K 1 footnote 120; Orchos Shabbos 2:26; Piskeiy Teshuvos 254:6
Other Articles
✍️ From the Rav’s Desk: Carrying in a Shared Courtyard with Gentile Neighbors
Post Views: 42 Question: I currently live in a small four‑unit condominium (similar to a townhouse structure), with a single shared outdoor courtyard that is fully enclosed by a gate. Of the four tenants, three are non‑Jewish, and I am the only Jewish resident. Am I required to make an
✍️ From the Rav’s Desk: The Validity of a Pledge of a Now‑Deceased Man
Post Views: 57 Question Dear Rabbi, A very wealthy individual, with whom both my friend and I were well acquainted and on very good terms, told us on several occasions—while we were visiting him in his home—that after he passes away, we may take several items that belong to him.
✍️ From the Rav’s Desk: Tevilat Keilim While Wearing a Glove
Post Views: 41 Question: It is very cold outside, and I would like to know if it is permitted to immerse (toivel) utensils in the mikvah while wearing a glove. Is this allowed? Answer: Yes, there is no issue with immersing utensils while wearing a glove. However, one must ensure
✍️ From the Rav’s Desk: Permissibility of Plucking Fruit and Herbs from Plants Growing in a Cemetery
Post Views: 91 ✍️ From the Rav’s Desk: Permissibility of Plucking Fruit and Herbs from Plants Growing in a Cemetery Question: Dear Rabbi, I was recently visiting a very beautiful and well‑kept Jewish cemetery. Inside the cemetery grounds there were fig trees bearing fruit, as well as numerous rosemary
✍️ From the Rav’s Desk: Permissibility of Torah Study and Prayer in the Presence of a Woman’s Perfume
Post Views: 126 Question: Dear Rabbi, I would like to ask about a situation I recently encountered. I was traveling on the subway and seated across from a woman who was dressed in a manner that was not modest. At the time, I was learning from the daily learning packet
✍️ From the Rav’s Desk: Giving a Child a Haircut During Sefirah
Post Views: 81 Question We have an upcoming wedding of a family member after Lag Baomer, and my child’s hair is in desperate need of a haircut to look representable at the wedding. We are Chabad and generally observe the mourning customs of Sefirah until ערב שבועות and hence avoid
Leave A Comment?
You must be logged in to post a comment.