Question:
I met an elderly Jewish woman at an old age home who when I asked her if she would like to say a blessing over candle lighting before Shabbos, she was very excited to do so, however asked me if it was allowed for her to say the blessing, as she recalls when growing up in Europe that her parents would often tell the girls not to say blessings and at times her father would say the blessing over the candles and not her mother, and since then whenever she lit candles for Shabbos [which was not often because she was not brought up in a Jewish home after the war] she did it without a blessing. I found this very strange, although of course I can simply dismiss it as a cloudy memory on her part, I just wanted to check if there’s any truth to this concept in Jewish law or tradition?
Answer:
In general, women are obligated in the saying of blessings just as men. It could be that the elderly woman was remembering specific blessings that women don’t say, such as Shelo Asani Isha, or blessings over mitzvahs that they’re not obligated in, by which there are Sephardic Poskim who rule that they cannot say the blessing and perhaps in her family they were stringent like this opinion. However, regarding candle lighting for Shabbos everyone agrees that a woman says the blessing. Nonetheless, it is possible that her family followed an old Ashkenazi tradition, which is no longer practiced, and has been negated by the Poskim, which is for girls and women not to recite any blessings when they are in a state of Nida, and hence it could be that during these times her father said the blessing over the candle lighting. Now, although as I said we do not rule this way, it could be that her mother’s family followed this Old tradition, and never updated to the final Halachic ruling. Practically, women [including a woman who is a Nida ] are obligated in the recital blessings prior and post eating a food and prior to benefiting one of the benefits that a blessing was instituted for.
See Admur 88:2; M”A 88:2; Rama 88:1; Darkei Moshe 88:1; Y.D. 195:8; Ravayah 68; Hagahos Maimanis Tefila 4 Gimel; Binyamon Zev 153; Or Zarua 1:360; Kaf Hachaim 88:10; Darkei Teshuvah Y.D. 195:58; Shulchan Melachim Nida 4; Yalkut Hagershoni 658:5; Nitei Gavriel 41:3
Question:
I own a pair tefillin which I use only for Mivtzaim, which I usually do once a week on Fridays. I would like to know if I must check them every year, or how often they should be checked?
Answer:
It is not a requirement check them annually, although certainly one is encouraged to do so, just as you are encouraged to check your own tefillin once a year. At the very least, they must be checked every 3 ½ years. [The tefillin that you wear daily h from letter of the law does not ever require checking [so long as nothing potentially damaging was witnessed to happen to them], however, the Mivtzaim Tefillin which are only worn once a week must from the letter of the law be checked once every 3 ½ years.]
Sources: See regarding checking Tefillin twice in seven years if worn only on occasion: Admur 39:11; Michaber 39:10; Orchos Chaim Tefillin 29; Haittur Tefillin Chelek Hateshi; Shaareiy Teshuvah 153; See Regarding that we don’t know the definition of “occasion” and hence any Tefillin not worn daily is to be checked every 3.5 years: Mateh Yehuda 39:8; Kol Yaakov 39:39
Other Articles
From the Rav’s Desk: Walking behind one’s Rebbe & More
Post Views: 121 Walking behind one’s Rebbe Question: Is it permitted for one to walk behind his Rebbe? Answer: It is forbidden for one to walk to the side of ones Rebbe as this appears as if one views himself equal to his Rebbe and he is considered an
From the Ravs Desk: Q&A on Fish, feeding employees and an angry Get
Post Views: 110 Eating Live Fish Question: I have a theoretical question regarding the kashrus of fish. May one eat a live fish? Does it have a prohibition of Eiver Min Hachaiy? Answer: While the prohibition of Eiver Min Hachaiy does not apply to live fish and hence it
From the Rav’s Desk: Women saying blessings
Post Views: 116 Women and girls saying blessings Question: I met an elderly Jewish woman at an old age home who when I asked her if she would like to say a blessing over candle lighting before Shabbos, she was very excited to do so, however asked me if it
From the Rav’s Desk: Khat arla, Mi Shebeirach for Ger, nice vessel for Mayim Achronim
Post Views: 113 The status of the Khat leave regarding Arla and Teruma Umaasros Question: Is one required to separate Terumos Umaasros from the Khat plant whose leaves are used for chewing and swallowing the juice that comes out upon chewing it. The leaves are then spat out and
From the Rav’s Desk: Shaalos Veteshuvos on Aliyos, Bed Sharing, Shemoneh Esrei doubts
Post Views: 155 Sephardim don’t call up by name for Aliyah to the Torah Question: I was by a Sephardic Minyan and was motioned to go up to the Torah, and when I told the Gabaiy my name he did not repeat it and officially call me up and simply
From the Rav’s Desk: Shaalos Veteshuvos on October 7th & More
Post Views: 149 An ancient day of danger – Tekufas Tishreiy on October 7 An ancient day of danger – Tekufas Tishreiy on October 7 Question: Someone mentioned to me that the secular date of October 7th is traditionally a day of bad omen according to Judaism, and is associated
Leave A Comment?
You must be logged in to post a comment.