0. List of soups and their blessings

This article is an excerpt from the above Sefer

*As an Amazon Associate I earn from  qualifying purchases.

WhatsApp
Telegram
Facebook
Twitter

List of soups and their blessings[1]

*In all cases, this chart refers to non-Pureed soups which were cooked with intent to eat both their solid and liquid, and soup mix was not added.

Soup Name [In Alphabetical order] Blessing on soup when eaten with Solid [not Pureed] Blessing on Broth when eaten without solid food Soup Type  
Alphabet soup Mezonos Mezonos Mezonos
Apple Soup Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Apple and Pear Soup Haeitz Shehakol Fruit
Blueberry Soup Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Barley [chopped] soup Mezonos Mezonos Grain
Barley [whole kernel without peel] soup Dispute[2] Shehakol Grain
Barley [whole with peel] soup Ha’adama, Dispute after blessing[3] Shehakol Grain
Beef Stew Shehakol Shehakol Meat
Bean Soup Ha’adama Ha’adama Vegetable
Borscht – Beet Soup [cooked in vinegar] Ha’adama Shehakol [Bedieved, Ha’adama] Vegetable
Borscht – Beet Soup [cooked in water] Ha’adama Ha’adama Vegetable
Cantaloupe Soup Ha’adama Shehakol Fruit
Chilled Peach Soup Haeitz Shehakol Fruit
Curried Butternut Squash and Apple Soup Ha’adama/Haeitz Shehakol Fruit
Cream of Mushroom Soup Shehakol Shehakol Vegetable
Cherries Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Chicken Noodle Soup Mezonos Mezonos Meat
Cucumber Soup Shehakol Shehakol Vegetable
lemon Shehakol Shehakol Fruit Compote
French Onion Soup Shehakol Shehakol Vegetable
Hulled Barley soup Ha’adama, Dispute after blessing[4] Shehakol Grain
Hungarian Sour Cherry Soup Haeitz Shehakol Fruit
Lentil Soup Ha’adama Ha’adama Vegetable
Mango Gazpacho Haeitz Shehakol Fruit
Matzah Ball soup Mezonos Shehakol or Ha’adama [if added Matzah balls at end of cooking] Mezonos
Noodle Soup Mezonos Mezonos Mezonos
Olive Haeitz Shehakol [Disputed after blessing] Fruit
Oranges Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Onion Shehakol Shehakol Vegetable
Peaches Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Pears Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Pea Soup Ha’adama Ha’adama Vegetable
Potato Leek Soup Ha’adama Ha’adama Vegetable
Plums Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Pumpkin and Apple Soup Ha’adama/Haeitz Shehakol Fruit
Raspberries Haeitz Shehakol Fruit Compote
Split Pea Soup Ha’adama Ha’adama Legume
Soup Mix powder Shehakol Shehakol Instant soup
Strawberry Soup Ha’adama Shehakol Fruit
Tomato Soup Ha’adama Shehakol Vegetable
Watermelon Gazpacho Shehakol Shehakol Fruit
Whole Wheat soup Ha’adama Shehakol Grain

Chart

  Intent to eat only liquid and drinking only liquid Intent to eat only the food and throw out liquid [ex. Pasta water] and now eating liquid Intent to eat both food and liquid together but now eating just liquid
Fruit soup Shehakol Shehakol Shehakol; Bedieved Haeitz
Vegetable soup Ha’adama Shehakol Ha’adama
Whole grain 5 Minim soup Shehakol Shehakol Shehakol; Bedieved Ha’adama
Crushed 5 Minim soup Shehakol Shehakol Mezonos
Lentil soup Shehakol Shehakol Ha’adama
Mezonos [alphabet] soup Shehakol Shehakol Mezonos
Chicken/meat soup Shehakol Shehakol Shehakol
Chicken vegi soup Shehakol Shehakol Shehakol

 

 

[1] If soup mix was added, see Halacha 1!

[2] The blessing over liquidy barley soup falls under the debate of whole grains which do not stick to each other, and hence is to be eaten within a meal [or alternatively according to some  say Ha’adama and Mezonos on a different food and eat enough of those foods to be able to say an after blessing of Al Hamichyah and Borei Nefashos after eating it.] When eating it outside of a meal [and without saying a blessing on other foods] some conclude that one should say Mezonos as a before blessing and Al Hamichya as an after blessing. If the barley sticks together in the soup, then according to all, the soup is Mezonso a nd Al Hamichyah. See Chapter 10 Halacha 10!

[3] There is a dispute on whether cooked hulled barley is Al Hamichyah or Borei Nefashos. Practically one is to say Borei Nefashos although it is best to eat within meal, or say two different blessings as stated in Chapter 10 Halacha 9A. To note that the after blessing is always Borei Nefashos if one did not eat a Kezayis of barley within Achilas Peras.

[4] There is a dispute on whether cooked hulled barley is Al Hamichyah or Borei Nefashos. Practically one is to say Borei Nefashos although it is best to eat within meal, or say two different blessings as stated in Chapter 10 Halacha 9A. To note that the after blessing is always Borei Nefashos if one did not eat a Kezayis of barley within Achilas Peras.

Was this article helpful?

Related Articles