Ask the Rav: Your Questions - Our Answers
A global inbox meets timeless wisdom. Ask the Rav is a series built entirely on authentic questions sent from Jews around the world — from Brooklyn to Be’er Sheva, Melbourne to Manchester. Each question is a real-life dilemma, curiosity, or challenge answered with thoughtful and grounded halachic guidance.
Chanukah Q&A
Answer:
Indeed, you are correct. According to halacha, the leftover oil and wicks should be burned right away, preferably by the next day, to ensure that one does not come to use them. This follows the general rule for all items that are forbidden for benefit: they should not remain in the home lest one accidentally derive benefit from them. While saving things to burn with the chametz is a virtuous concept, that only applies to items that are not prohibited for benefit—such as the aravos and lulav—but not to items like leftover Hanukkah oil and wicks, which are forbidden for benefit.
Sources:
See M”A 677:11; Tur 677; Levush; M”B 677:19; Kaf Hachaim 677:29; See our corresponding Sefer “The Laws of Chanukah” Chapter 3 Halacha 21D in Q&A; https://shulchanaruchharav.com/owning-non-kosher-food/ ; https://shulchanaruchharav.com/halacha/from-the-ravs-desk-saving-the-leftover-wicks-and-oil-of-the-menorah-for-the-burning-of-chametz-on-erev-pesach/
Question:
What should be done if, on Shabbos Rosh Chodesh Teves (which requires reading from three Sifrei Torah), only two Torah scrolls are available? This situation occurred in our Shul and there was a debate whether we should read the Chanukah reading from the first scroll or from the second scroll. If read from the first scroll, it would require more rolling; if read from the second scroll, it would require less rolling. What is the correct approach?
Answer:
In such a case, the best approach is to roll the first Torah scroll to the Chanukah reading prior to the time it is needed, which can be done between aliyos during Mi Shebeirach that takes place before Maftir. If this was not done and now the choice is between rolling the first scroll or rolling the second scroll, then it is better to roll the second scroll, which is already at the Rosh Chodesh reading and is closer to the Chanukah reading than the first scroll.
Explanation:
If only two Torah scrolls are available, the Poskim rule that the following procedure should be followed:
- Read the weekly Parsha from the first scroll.
- Read the Parsha of Rosh Chodesh from the second scroll.
- Read the extra Parsha (for Chanukah) from the first scroll, provided that the first scroll was rolled to the extra Parsha before it is needed for the third reading.
If the first scroll was not rolled to the extra Parsha beforehand, it is preferable to read the extra Parsha from the second scroll. However, if the extra Parsha is adjacent to the weekly Parsha (such as by Parshas Shekalim), then one should read from the first scroll even if it was not rolled prior to Hagbah.
Sources:
Rama 669:1 “In a place where they have only two Torah scrolls, they read in the first one V’Zot HaBerachah, and in the second one Bereishit. Then they return and take the first one again for the reading of the day. And this is what should be done in every place where three Torah scrolls are required but only two are available.”; Peri Chadash 684; Shulchan Gavoa 684:11; Shalmei Chagiga Inyan Kerias Hatorah Bemoados Simchas Torah 134 in name of Emes Leyaakov; Shaareiy Efraim Shaar 8:6; Kaf Hachaim 684:16; Mikraeiy Kodesh 2 29:28; Shulchan Hakeria 21:20; Yikra Detzibura p. 381; Chemed Moshe 669; Kaf Hachaim 669:41; Biur Halacha 669:1 “Vechozrim” “This applies specifically when it has already been rolled to that place, so that the congregation will not need to wait. But otherwise, it is better to roll the scroll that is already placed there, and not to transgress the principle of ein ma’avirin al ha‑mitzvot (one should not pass
Other Articles
From the Ravs Desk: The Shabbos That Vanished: Halacha on the High Seas When Crossing The Dateline
Post Views: 36 The Shabbos That Vanished: Halacha on the High Seas When Crossing The Dateline Question: Rabbi, I’m on a cruise ship traveling from Hawaii toward Australia, and late Friday afternoon the ship crossed the International Date Line. According to the ship’s clocks, we skipped completely over Saturday daytime
From the Rav’s Desk: Is It Really Forbidden According To Halacha to Draw the Sun, Moon, and Stars?
Post Views: 23 Is It Really Forbidden According To Halacha to Draw the Sun, Moon, and Stars? Question: I was in the middle of drawing a picture of the world—sun, moon, stars, grass, trees, animals—like I always enjoy doing during class. My teacher stopped me and said that not
From the Rav’s Desk: Who has the greatest Yetzer Harah? The Tzadik?! (Tuesday, 23rd Shevat)
Post Views: 19 Question: I have a question regarding a Mamar Chazal that has always bothered me. Chazal [sukkah 52a] teach that “the greater a person is, the greater their yetzer hara is.” At first glance this seems strange. If so, does it mean that simple Jews would have small
From the Rav’s Desk: When Restitution Isn’t Ribis: Paying More Than You Have To When Returning Stolen Money (Monday, 22nd Shevat)
Post Views: 28 Issur Ribis when returning stolen money Question: Years ago, during a moment of desperation, I stole $500 cash from my roommates’ unattended drawer. They realized it was missing, but never knew that I stole it. Now, with my life steady I want to return the money and
From the Rav’s Desk: May a Kohen Who Publicly Violates Shabbos Perform Birkat Kohanim – Duchaning? (Sunday, 21st Shevat)
Post Views: 30 May a Kohen Who Publicly Violates Shabbos Perform Birkat Kohanim – Duchaning? Question: There is an individual in our community who is a Kohen but who drives to synagogue on Shabbos and Yom Tov. Is it permissible for such a person to perform Birkat Kohanim (Duchaning)?
From the Rav’s Desk: Help! I Used a Meat Knife to slice tomato’s that I placed into my cheese toast sandwich (Thursday, 18th Shevat)
Post Views: 47 Question: I accidentally used a clean fleishig (meat) knife to slice a tomato for my cheese sandwich and only realized afterward. I put the tomato into my cheese sandwich, and the sandwich went into the toaster/sandwich maker. Am I allowed to eat it? Answer: As long as
