The Torah Reading of RH

This article is an excerpt from our Sefer

Buy me here or on Amazon.com

The Torah Reading:[1]

A. Background:

Moshe Rabbeinu established for the Jewish people that on every Yom Tov one is to read the Torah portion dealing with that Holiday.[2] The Sages of the Mishneh and Gemara chose the exact portion of the Torah that is read on each holiday.[3]

The amount of Aliyos:[4] Moshe instituted that five men be called up for an Aliyah by the Torah reading of the first Torah scroll.[5]

Haftorah:[6] The reading of the Haftorah was instituted by the Anshei Kneses Hagedola.[7] They instituted that one should read from Navi on every holiday from a portion that deals with the holiday events. The Sages of the Mishneh and Gemara chose the exact portion of Navi that is read on each holiday.

The Maftir:[8] [Maftir in truth refers to the reading of the portion from Navi formally known as the Haftorah. It comes from the word Petor which means finish, as the reading is completed with the Haftorah.] However, the person that reads the Maftir from Navi is also required to first read a section from the Torah.[9] In the times of the Sages of the Mishneh and Talmud the Maftir would read from the Torah as part of the five Aliyos that were read from the portion of that Holiday which was read from the first Torah scroll. [There was hence no second scroll taken out from the ark] However, in later generations, the Rabanan Savuraiy established, and so was accustomed by the Geonim which followed them, that the Maftir is to read [from a second scroll] the portion of the Musaf sacrifice written in Parshas Pinchas. This institution was based on the following teaching of the Sages: Avraham stated in front of Hashem “Master of the world when the Temple is not in existence the children of Israel do not have on what to find support. What will be with my children when they sin? Perhaps you will do to them as you did to the generation of the Mabul and Haflaga. Hashem answered “I have already established for them the order of the Karbanos. When the Karbanos are read, I consider it as if they sacrificed the Karban before me and I forgive all of their sins.  [Regarding why the Maftir is read as the sixth Aliyah and is not part of the five Aliyos-see chapter 282/10-13!]

Two Torah scrolls:[10] Being that two different sections of the Torah need to be read on Yom Tov[11], therefore, one is initially required to remove two Torah scrolls; one for the Holiday reading, and the second for the Maftir. It does not suffice to remove only one Torah scroll and then roll it to the Parsha of Musafim [for Maftir].[12]

 

B. Saying Hashem Hashem:[13]

On Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur [when the Ark is opened to remove the Torah scrolls] the 13 attributes [i.e. passage of Hashem Hashem] is recited three times prior to Berich Shmei.[14] [This applies even when [the first day of] Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbos. The same applies when Yom Kippur falls on Shabbos.[15]] After the recital of Hashem Hashem one recites the prayer of Ribono Shel Olam[16] [one time[17]]. [Likewise the verse of Veani Sefilasi, which is recited after the Ribono Shel Olam is only recited one time.[18]] This is then followed by the prayer of Berich Shmei.[19]

How many Torah Scrolls are removed?[20] Two Torah scrolls are removed from the Ark. [The scrolls are to be rolled to their proper places prior to Davening. Doing so is not to be delayed until Kerias Hatorah.[21] If only one scroll is available then the two portions are to be read from the same scroll.[22]]

The reading of the first Torah Scroll:[23] [On the first day of Rosh Hashanah] one reads from the first Torah scroll the portion starting with “And Hashem remembered Sarah” up until the section of the Akeida. This portion is read because [it discusses the remembrance of G-d’s promise to Sarah that she will have a child and] it was on Rosh Hashanah that she was remembered [by Hashem and conceived].[24] [This hints to the idea that we also should be remembered by Hashem for blessing of goodness on this day.[25]]

The Aliyos of the first Torah scroll:[26] Five men are called up for an Aliyah by the Torah reading of the first Torah scroll. When Rosh Hashanah coincides with Shabbos seven men are called up to the reading of the first Torah scroll.[27]

Who is to receive an Aliyah?[28] [The Aliyah’s are to be given to married men of stature out of respect for the day.[29]] Some communities have a custom to give one of the five Aliyos[30] to the Baal Tokeia.[31] Other communities[32] are accustomed in addition to the above to also give an Aliyah to the Chazan of Musaf. The same applies on Yom Kippur.[33] [The above people are considered Chiyuvim in areas that follow this custom. However this only applies if the Baal Tokeia and Chazan do not take money for their work. However those Chazanim and Baalei Tokeia that get paid are not considered a Chiyuv at all.[34] Nevertheless some[35] write that it is proper to give them an Aliyah even in such a case. Some Poskim[36] rule that the above law however is only in a case that the Aliyah’s are not sold in the Shul. If however the Aliyos are sold then there are no Chiyuvim, even for the Baal Tokeia, Baal Tefila, Baal Yartzite, Sandek etc, and all the Aliyos may be sold to highest bidder. See Q&A for further details.]

Maftir-The Second Torah Scroll:[37] [After the above reading and recital of half Kaddish[38]] the Maftir is read from the second Torah from the portion of Pinchas “Ubechodesh Hashevi”. [This portion discusses the sacrifices of Rosh Hashanah that were brought on Rosh Hashanah in the Temple.]

The Haftorah:[39] The Haftorah is read from the beginning of Sefer Shmuel until the words “Vayerem Keren Meshicho”. [The reason it is read is because it discusses the events of Chana’s pregnancy] as also Chana conceived on Rosh Hashanah.[40]

When to return the Torah to the Aron:[41] The Torah scroll is left out throughout the Shofar blowing and is thus only returned before Musaf. [The prevalent custom amongst Anash is that the Sefer Torah is placed on the Bimah during the Shofar blowing, however in 770 the custom is for it to be held.[42]]

 

Reading on the Second day of Rosh Hashanah:[43]

How many scrolls are removed?[44] Two Torah scrolls are removed from the ark.

Reading of first scroll: On the second day of Rosh Hashanah one reads the portion of the Akeida from the first Torah scroll, starting with “And Elokim tested Avraham” up until the end of the Parsha. This portion is read in order to remind [Hashem] of the Akeida of Yitzchak.[45]

Maftir: The person who reads the Haftorah reads for Maftir [from the second scroll] the same portion of the Torah that was read yesterday [the first day of Rosh Hashanah].

Haftorah: The Haftorah is read from Yermia, starting from the words “Ko Amar etc” until the words “Haben Yakir etc”. The reason for why we read this Haftorah is because it is an obligation to awaken the memory on Rosh Hashanah, and in this Haftorah it states “Zechor Ezkerenu Od Al Kein Hamu Meiay”.[46]

 

General laws and customs

Getting an Aliyah:

It is proper for every G-d fearing Jew to try to get an Aliyah during the High Holidays. If the Aliyah’s are sold then he should try to purchase an Aliyah in accordance to the amount that he can afford.[47] Nevertheless one must beware from this leading towards strife and discord as one should not fight over any Mitzvah and one who compromises to the other person is also meritorious. This applies even if one desires to get an Aliyah on behalf of a deceased relative, as the compromise serves as an even greater merit.[48]

 

Selling the Aliyos:

Some Poskim[49] write against the custom of selling the Aliyos on Rosh Hashanah as perhaps an unbefitting person will buy the Aliyah.

 

May one sell the Aliyahs of Kohen and Levi to the highest bitter?

Some Poskim[50] rule it is permitted to sell to the highest bidder even the Aliyah of Kohen and Levi, as the Kohen only receives precedence when the Aliya’s are not being sold. Other[51] Poskim however forbid doing so. Practically one who desires to do so is to have the Kohanim exit the Shul prior to the Aliyah of Kohen.[52]

 

The tune of the Torah reading:

It is a known custom amongst all Israel to read the Torah on Rosh Hashanah in a special tune of the Yamim Noraim. This is also the Chabad custom. Nevertheless in Lubavitch the custom was to read the Maftir from the second scroll in the regular reading tune and not with the tune of the High Holidays.[53] 

The Brachos:[54] The custom is for the person who receives the Aliyah to recite the blessings of Birchas Hatorah in the hymn of the Rosh Hashanah reading. The same applies to reading the Mi Shebeirach. One should not swerve from this custom. [Nevertheless the blessings of the Maftir and Haftorah are said in the regular tune according to the Chabad custom as explained above.[55]]

 

Mi Shebeirach:

Some Poskim[56] write that one should not recite the words “Lekavod Yom Hadin” being that these are days of mercy. Practically the Chabad custom is to say “Lekavod Yom Hadin”.[57]

Mi Shebeirach for the sick: Upon saying a Mi Shebeirach for the sick it is not necessary to say “Shabbos Hi Melizok” or “Yom Tov Hi Melizok” as today is the day of judgment.[58]

 

The following is the Chabad Nussach for Mi Shebeirach:[59]

 מי שברך אבותינו אברהם יצחק ויעקב הוא יברך את) פב״פ (בעבור שעלה לתורה לכבוד המקום ולכבוד התורה ולכבוד יום הדין, בשכר זה [הקב״ה [ישמרהו ויצילהו מכל צרה וצוקה ומכל נגע ומחלה, ויכתבהו ויחתמהו לחיים טובים בזה יום הדין, וישלח ברכה והצלחה בכל מעשה ידיו עם כל ישראל אחיו ונאמר אמן.

 

Mistakes in the reading

The fourth Aliyah was read until the end of the portion:[60]

If the reader accidently read until the end of the Parsha by the Aliyah of Revii [4th Aliyah] then the 5th Aliyah is to read the next portion, which is the portion of the Akeida. If however one already recited Kaddish after the fourth Aliyah then the Maftir from the second scroll is to count as the 5th Aliyah.

 

Read the portion of the Akeida on the first day:[61]

If the reader accidently read the parsha of the Akeida on the first day then if the last Aliyah [5th Aliyah] did not yet recite the after blessing, the reader is to retract to the beginning of the correct portion, from “Vehashem Pakad Es Sarah”. After the correct portion is read the person of the 5th Aliyah recites the after blessing. If however he already said the after blessing and then they remembered that they read the wrong portion then they are to continue with Maftir and the next day are to read the section that was supposed to be read the previous day, from “Vehashem Pakad..” until the end of the Akeida.

 

Read the portion of the Vehashem Pakad also on the second day:[62]

If the reader accidently read the Parsha of Vehashem Pakad also on the second day then if the last Aliyah [5th Aliyah] did not yet recite the after blessing, the reader is to now read the portion of the Akeida. If however he already said the after blessing and then they remembered that they read the wrong portion then another person is to be called up for a 6th Aliyah and read the portion of the Akeida. This applies even if Kaddish was already recited, in which case a second Kaddish is recited after the reading. This applies even if Hagba was already performed to the first Torah scroll, in which case they are to read the Akeida from the second scroll and then recite Kaddish and call up the Maftir.

 

Skipped part of the beginning of the portion:[63]

If by the first Aliyah the reader accidently began reading from further on in the Parsha, skipping the section dealing with the remembrance of Sarah, then by the next Aliyah he is to start from the beginning and read up until Shelishi.

 

Bringing a Sefer Torah to a private Minyan:[64]

One may not bring a Sefer Torah to people that are incarcerated [or sick[65] and the like and are hence unable to make it to Kerias Hatorah]. This applies even on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.[66] [This however only applies to a case that there is less than a Minyan of people that need the Sefer Torah.[67] If however there is a Minyan of people that are unable to make it to Kerias Hatorah due to reasons against their will then a Sefer Torah may be brought to that Minyan.[68] If however the Minyan is able to make it to Shul then a Sefer Torah may not be brought to them unless one of the following exceptions apply:]

Setting up an Aron for the Torah:[69] The above prohibition only applies if the Torah scroll is being brought to the Minyan at the time of Kerias Hatorah [and returned after the reading], if however [an ark[70] is prepared for the Torah scroll[71] and] it remains there for a day or two then it is permitted to be brought. [This allowance applies whether it will remain a day or two prior to the reading or after the reading.[72] This allowance applies even if the people are able to come to Shul but they have a justified reason for desiring to make their own Minyan.[73] Nevertheless in all cases it must be brought before Davening and not simply when they reach Kerias Hatorah.[74] Some Poskim[75] rule that in addition to the above conditions [setting up an ark and leaving it for one to two days] one is not to return the Sefer Torah until it is read on three different occasions. Practically the widespread custom is like this opinion in order to show that the Torah was given a set place in the area.[76]]

A Gadol Betorah: [Another exception to the above prohibition is as follows:] If the person that requires the Sefer Torah to be brought to him is a Gadol Betorah, then it is permitted to be brought[77] [even if he is the only person that requires the reading, and even if an area is not prepared for the Sefer Torah[78]]. [Nevertheless it is disputed whether this is permitted even if the Gadol is able to make it to Shul. Practically if he is able to make it to Shul then an Aron is to be set up by his house to allow the Torah scroll to be brought according to all opinions.[79]]

 

Summary:

It is permitted to bring a Sefer Torah to another area in the following cases:

  1. There are ten people that are unable to come to Shul due to reasons beyond their will.
  2. There is a Gadol Betorah that is unable to come to Shul due to reasons beyond his will.
  3. The Sefer Torah is set up in an ark some time prior to the Keria and remains there for one to two days, [and one reads from the Torah at least on three different occasions].

 

Q&A

May a Sefer Torah be brought from one room to another within the same Shul?

Yes.[80] However there are Poskim[81] that are stringent in this matter.

 

May a Sefer Torah be brought to a Chabad house Minyan that is established especially for Rosh Hashanah?

Yes. An ark is to be set up for the Sefer Torah and the Sefer Torah is to remain there a day or two.

 

May people make a separate Minyan by Kerias Hatorah in a nearby house, bringing the Sefer Torah with them?[82]

It was accustomed by some congregations that when the time of Kerias Hatorah arrived a Minyan within the congregation would take a Sefer Torah with them to a nearby home and read the Torah there in order so everyone can get an Aliyah. The Poskim[83] negate this practice based on the ruling above. Nevertheless if the Aliyos will be sold and the charity funds will increase as a result then it is permitted to be done.[84] Nevertheless it is best to set up an Ark for the scroll and leave it there for a day or two.

___________________________________

[1] 584/7; Michaber 584/2

[2] Admur ibid; 282/1; M”A 135/1; 535; Rambam Tefila 13/8; Mishneh Megillah 31a

The hint in scripture: The above institution is hinted to in the verse “Vayidaber Moshe Es Moadeiy Hashem El Bnei Yisrael”, from which we learn that Moshe established that each Prasha of the Moadim is to be read at its proper time. [Admur ibid]

[3] Admur ibid; Megillah ibid

[4] Admur 282/1; 488/5; M”A 135/1

[5] The reason: The reason behind the different number of Aliyos [Three during the week; Four on Rosh Chodesh; Five on Yom Tov; six on Rosh Hashanah; seven on Shabbos] is based on the levels of holiness that each day contains over the other days. See 282/1 for further details on this matter.

[6] Admur 488/5

[7] Admur ibid; Sefer Hamachria 31 in name of Rabbeinu Tma that it was instituted by Ezra

[8] Admur 488/6

[9] Admur 282/10; 488/6

[10] Admur 488/6; Michaber 144/3

[11] One must read from the Parsha of the Holiday, as per the institution of Moshe Rabbeinu, and one msut also read the Karbanaos from Parshas Pinchas, as per the instititution of the Rabanan Savuraiy.

[12] The reason: As one may not roll a Sefer Torah in front of the congregation due to respect of the congregation. [Admnur ibid]

[13] Siddur Admur

[14] It is not customary to recite the words “Vayavor Hashem Al Panav” prior to saying it being that the Hashem Hashem is recited as a prayer and not as a verse in the Torah. [Halichos Olam brought in Piskeiy Teshuvos 584 footnote 16, unlike Mateh Efraim 584/584/16; Otzer Minhagei Chabad 206].

[15] Implication of Admur in Siddur [that by R”H he does not differentiate between the weekday and Shabbos]; Sefer Haminhagim p. 119 [English Edition]; Hayom Yom 10th Tishrei; Hisvadus 6th Tishrei 1970; Shaareiy Teshuvah 488/1; Likkutei Mahrich Pesach based on Ramaz; Custom brought in M”E 584/16; Luach Eretz Yisrael; See Otzer Minhagei Chabad 210; Piskeiy Teshuvos 488/3

Other Opinions: Some Poskim write that the 13 attributes are to be omitted when Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbos. [Hagahos Marsham and Daas Torah 488 in name of Shut Beshamayim Rosh 71 in name of Geonim; M”E 584/16; Shaareiy Efraim 10/65; Darkei Chaim Veshalom 715]

[16] This prayer was established with Ruach Hakodesh by the Arizal. [Piskeiy Teshuvos 584/3; See Kaf Hachaim 134/11; Shaar Hakavanos p. 89] On Rosh Hashanah the words “Umechol Al Kol Avonosaiy” is omitted as we do not mention sin on Rosh Hashanah. [See Siddur Admur; Otzer Minhagei Chabad 205]

[17] Shaareiy Teshuvah 488 [“so is the custom”]; implication of Admur in Siddur [Rav Raskin p. 300]

Other Opinions: According to the Arizal one is to recite the prayer of Ribono Shel Olam three times. [Peri Eitz Chaim Shaar Tefilos R”H]

[18] Implication of Admur in Siddur and so is the Chabad custom

Other customs: Some have the custom to recite the verse of Veani Sefilasi three times. [Peri Eitz Chaim Shaar R”H; Siddur Shlah]

[19] Siddur Admur; Ketzei Hamateh 619/48 [so is custom of world] unlike the custom brought in Shaareiy Efraim 10/5 and Mateh Efraim 619/48

[20] Admur ibid

Background behind removing two Torah scrolls:

Being that it was instituted to read the Maftir from the portion of Pinchas, as explained below in the footnotes the reason behind this institution, therefore two scrolls must be removed from the Ark. It does not suffice to remove one scroll and then roll it to the next portion of Musafim found in Pinchas as we do not roll the Torah scroll in front of the congregation due to respect of the public. [488/6; see 144/3]

[21] See M”B 144/13

[22] Michaber 144/3; Although the scroll will need to be rolled to the proper place of the second reading, after completing the first reading, nevertheless since there is no other scroll available we allow it to be rolled and differ the “respect of the Tzibur”. [ibid; See M”B 144/16]

[23] Admur ibid

The background of Torah reading:

It was established by Moshe Rabbeinu, that on every Yom Tov one is to read the Torah portion dealing with that Holiday. The Sages of the Mishneh and Gemara chose the exact portion of the Torah that is read on each holiday. [see 488/5]

General laws: The general laws of the Torah reading can be found in Chapter 282. The following are the laws discussed there: May one add more Aliyos? [282/1-4]; Who may get an Aliyah? [282/5]

[24] Admur ibid; Levush; M”A 584/2; M”B 584/6 [Rachel and Chana were also remembered on Rosh Hashanah]

[25] Kaf Hachaim 584/15

[26] Admur ibid

The background of the Aliyos:

It was established by Moshe Rabbeinu that on every Yom Tov there should be five people called up to read the Torah portion dealing with that Holiday. [282/1;488/5; M”A 135/1] The reason behind the different number of Aliyos [Three during the week; Four on Rosh Chodesh; Five0 on Yom Tov; six on Rosh Hashanah; seven on Shabbos] is based on the levels of holiness that each day contains over the other days. See 282/1 for further details on this matter.

[27] 584/7

[28] 584/7

[29] M”A 136/1 in name of Mahril; Mateh Efraim 584/20

[30] Can he receive Maftir? Yes. The reason the Rama records “the five Aliyos” is in order to negate giving him a 6th or 7th Aliyah in those areas that add more Aliyah’s to the reading. [Shaareiy Efraim 2/15; Ketzei Hamateh 584/34]+

[31] Admur 584/8; Rama 584/2 in name of Kol Bo

The reason: As the Torah brings joy to a person and hence the Chazan and Baal Tokeia will be in a joyful mood and not come to make a mistake in the prayer and blowing. [Levush 584]

[32] The community of Pozna. [Levush and M”A 584/6]

[33] Admur ibid; M”A 584/6 ; Levush

[34] Kitzur Shlah; Elya Raba 584/9; Machatzis Hashekel; P”M 584 A”A 6; M”E 584/22; M”B 584/9; Kaf Hachaim 584/24

[35] Alef Hamagen 584/27 based on the reason of the Levush recorded above.

[36] Aruch Hashulchan 584/3; Shaareiy Efraim 2/15 regarding a Baal Yartzite and Sandek

[37] The background of Maftir:

Maftir in truth refers to the reading of the portion from Navi formally known as the Haftorah. It comes from the word Petor which means finish, as the reading is completed with the Haftorah. However the person that reads the Maftir from Navi is required to first read a section from the Torah. [282/10; 488/6] In the times of the Sages of the Mishneh and Talmud the Maftir would read from the Torah as part of the five Aliyos that were read from the portion of that Holiday which was read from the first Torah scroll. [There was hence no second scroll taken out from the ark] However in later generations the Rabanan Savuraiy established, and so was accustomed by the Geonim which followed them, that the Maftir is to read [from a second scroll] the portion of the Musaf sacrifice written in Parshas Pinchas. [488/6] Regarding why the Maftir is read as the sixth Aliyah and is not part of the five Aliyos-see chapter 282/10-13!

The meaning behind reading specifically the Musaf sacrifice for Maftir: The above institution of the Sages to read the portion of the Karbanos of Musaf was based on the following teaching of the Sages: Avraham stated in front of Hashem “Master of the world when the Temple is not in existence the children of Israel do not have on what to find support. What will be with my children when they sin? Perhaps you will do to them as you did to the generation of the Mabul and Haflaga. Hashem answered “I have already established for them the order of the Karbanos. When the Karbanos are read I consider it as if they sacrificed the Karban before me and I forgive all of their sins. [488/6]

[38] See 282/12 for the reason why Kaddish is recited between the five Aliyos and Maftir.

[39] The background of Haftorah:

The reading of the Haftorah was instituted by the Anshei Kneses Hagedola. They instituted that one should read from Navi on every holiday from a portion that deals with the holiday events. The Sages of the Mishneh and Gemara chose the exact portion of Navi that is read on each holiday. [488/5]

The laws of the Haftorah: Laws that relate to the Haftorah can be found in chapter 284 of the laws of Shabbos. The following are the laws discussed there: Amount of verses to read. [284/1]; The blessings [284/2] Can it be read from a Chumash. [284/4] Having in mind the 100 blessings. [46/1; 284/7] Having a Katan read. [284/8] When to begin the Haftorah. [284/11]

[40] This section is read being it discusses the remembrance of Chana by Hashem and her receiving a blessing for children on Rosh Hashanah. This is similar to the section read in the scroll regarding Sarah.

[41] 590/21; Rama 590/9; Tur 591; Levush 591; Kaf Hachaim 585/9

Other customs: The Rambam [Halacha 10] rules that the Torah scroll is to be returned to the Aron prior to the Shofar blowing. [Kaf Hachaim ibid] Regarding those congregations that are accustomed to all immerse in a Mikveh prior to the blowing and what they are to do with the Sefer Torah in the interim-see Piskeiy Teshuvos 585/1 and Poskim mentioned there!

[42] Otzer Minhagei Chabad 240

[43] 601/1; Michaber 601/1

[44] 584/7

[45] Other reasons: It is also read to remember the ram of Yitzchak as it is for this reason that we blow the Shofar using the horn of a ram. [Ran] Alternatively, the reason is because the Zohar [Vayikra 18] states that Akeidas Yitzchak took place on Rosh Hashanah. However in Pirkei Derebbe Eliezer it states that the Akeida took place on Yom Kippur. [Mateh Yehuda 584 brought in Kaf Hachaim 584/16] Some explain that the statement in the Zohar is not to be taken literally and it means to say the level of Gevurah, as Gevurah is called Yitzchak. [Machazik Bracha 2; Shalmei Tzibur 272 brought in Kaf Hachaim ibid]

[46] Admur ibid; Beis Yosef in name of Ran; Levush

[47] Mateh Efraim 584/17; M”B 584/8’ Kaf Hachaim 584/23

[48] Kaf Hachaim 584/23

[49] Mateh Efraim 584/17; Kaf Hachaim 584/22

[50] Mahrik brought in M”B 135/18; Shulchan Hatahor Komrana 135/8; Shoel Umeishiv 6/29

[51] See Teshuvah Meahava 90; Avnei Tzedek 9; Maharam Brisk 6

[52] Maharam Shick 59; Kaf Hachaim 135/14; Piskeiy Teshuvos 584/4

[53] Rav Yaakov Landau, Rav Nachman Refael Kahn, Rav Mordechai Shusterman, brought in Otzer Minhagei Chabad 215-216

[54] Mateh Efraim 584/18; Otzer Minhagei Chabad 212

[55] So was the Rebbe’s custom when he was called up for Maftir on Rosh Hashanah. [Otzer 220]

[56] Darkei Chaim Veshalom 715

[57] Otzer Minhagei Chabad 213; See Shaar Hakolel 26/5; Nesivos Bisade Hashlichos 1 p. 312

[58] M”E 584/25

[59] Siddur Torah Or and Machzor Chabad; Otzer Minhagei Chabad 214; however in some later prints of the Chabad Machzorim there are slight differences in Nusach.

[60] Shaareiy Efraim 8/33; brought in M”B 584/8; Kaf Hachaim 584/17; Ruling of Rav in Chasam Sofer 169, brought in Pischeiy Teshuvah

Other Opinions: Some Poskim rule that in such a case one is to always to have the Maftir count as the 5th Aliyah even if Kaddish was not recited. [Chasam Sofer ibid brought in M”B ibid and Kaf Hachaim ibid]

[61] Shaareiy Efraim 8/34; M”B 584/8; Kaf Hachaim 584/18; Toras Hashlamim 12/1-2

[62] Shaareiy Efraim 8/34; M”B 584/8; Kaf Hachaim 584/18; Toras Hashlamim 12/1-2

[63] Shaareiy Efraim 8/35; Kaf Hachaim 584/19; M”B 602/1

[64] Michaber 135/14; 584/3; based on Yerushalmi brought in Beis Yosef 135 “In all places we say one must go to the Sefer Torah and not have the Sefer Torah come to him”

[65] M”B 135/46; See M”A 135/23 in name of Or Zarua that argues that if the person is unable to make it to Shul for reasons against his will [such as he is sick] then he may have a Sefer Torah brought to him and read before a Minyan. The M”A ibid concludes that one may be lenient by Parshas Zachar. This ruling is recorded in M”B ibid.

[66] Michaber ibid

The reason: Although one desires to read the Torah with ten people on behalf of the prisoners or other people that are unable to hear the reading, and hence merit them with the Mitzvah, nevertheless one may not bring them the Sefer Torah as it is considered a belittlement to the Torah to bring it to others. Rather they are to come to the Torah. [M”B 135/47]

[67] M”B 135/47; Biur Halacha  “Ein Mavin”

The reason: As in such a case they are exempt from Kerias Hatorah, as an individual is not obligated to read the Torah. [Biur Halacha ibid]

[68] M”B 135/47; Biur Halacha  “Ein Mavin”

The reason: As a Minyan is obligated in hearing the Torah and since they are unable to make it to Shul due to reasons beyond their will, then there is no belittlement involved in bringing them a Torah scroll. [Biur Halacha ibid]

[69] Rama 135/14

[70] Any closet suffices to serve as an ark so long as it is respectful and clean of any other items. It does not have to specifically be an ark used for a Torah scroll. [Piskeiy Teshuvos 135/25]

[71] M”A 135/22 [“The main point is that the Torah has a Makom Kavua”]; M”B 135/49 in name of Achronim

[72] M”B 135/49 in name of Achronim

[73] Piskeiy Teshuvos 135/25

The following matters are considered justified reasons: One is sick; incarcerated; old and unable to walk; an Avel; a Minyan that Davens another Nussach etc. [See Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid]

[74] Poskim in Kaf Hachaim 584/26; Piskeiy Teshuvos 135/25

[75] Aruch Hashulchan 135/32; Toras Chaim Sofer 135/16; Igros Moshe 5/2-13; See Kinyan Torah 4/18; See Poskim in Nitei Gavriel 97/2 footnote 5

[76] Aruch Hashulchan ibid; Piskeiy Teshuvos 135/25

[77] Rama 135/14

[78] M”B 135/51

[79] M”B 135/50

[80] Mateh Yehuda 584/3; Ramatz 16; Beis Shlomo 34; Har Tzevi 71; Ashel Avraham Butchach 135 [that so is the custom] and so he rules in Daas Kedoshim 282; Piskeiy Teshuvos 135/23

The reason: As when it is all within the same building there is no belittlement to the Torah scroll when it is maneuvered.

[81] Maaseh Rav 129; Mor Uketzia 135; See Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid footnote 135

[82] M”B 135/48

[83] Elya Raba brought in M”B ibid; Aruch Hashulchan 135/32 [“Although they do so to receive an Aliyah, nevertheless by doing so they are transgressing an Aveira, and of all days on the High Holidays. Therefore it is proper to protest their actions and decree against them doing so.”]

[84] M”B ibid; not mentioned in Aruch Hashulchan ibid

Was this article helpful?

Related Articles

Leave A Comment?