Question
I consistently purchase omega-3 fish oil supplements that carry the highest level of kosher certification, specifically Badatz Edah HaChareidis. Recently, after making a substantial purchase of several bottles from a new store, I discovered that the product—although identical in appearance to the one certified by Badatz—is instead under standard Rabbanut supervision here in Israel. Given the significant financial investment, am I permitted to use these supplements, at least under extenuating circumstances (b’dieved)? Or should I attempt to return them and refrain from using them altogether?
Answer
Your commitment to purchasing fish oil with the highest level of kosher certification is commendable, particularly because the production process for omega-3 oils often involves blends that may include non-kosher fish sources. Nevertheless, in this situation—where the purchase has already been made—you may adopt a lenient approach for several reasons:
- Kosher Certification Exists: Although the supervision is not of the highest standard, the product does carry a recognized kosher certification.
- Form of Consumption: The supplement is ingested as a capsule, which is considered an atypical manner of eating (shelo k’derech achila), further reducing halachic concerns.
- Significant Financial Loss: Given the considerable expense involved, halacha allows for leniency in such cases.
Therefore, while it is ideal to maintain your usual standard, under these circumstances, you may rely on the existing certification and use the product.
Sources:
See Shach Y.D. 155:13; Yabia Omer 2:12; Hakashrus 11:21-22
