*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
WhatsApp
Telegram
Facebook
Twitter
There are various reasons for why a before blessing that was said over food may need to be repeated, either over that same food or over a different food of that same blessing.
- Speaking and other intervals: Speaking, and the performance of actions and other intervals are not considered a Hefsek which requires a blessing to be repeated unless they took place between the blessing and initial eating as explained in length in chapter 7 Halacha 3-4, and as will be explained in Halacha 7-8. However, once one has eaten and swallowed the initial food of the blessing, simply speaking and doing other actions between bites, do not constitute an interval to require blessing repetition, unless one of the following has taken place:
- Hesech Hadas: There are various different types of Hesech Hadas, or removal of the mind that may require blessing repetition. 1) A resolve to not eat any more of the food may require one to repeat the before blessing if one reconsiders. This is known as Nimlach. [Halacha 2] Likewise, 2) the recital of an after blessing is considered Hesech Hadas which requires blessing repetition. [Halacha 4-5] 3) Sleeping [Halacha 7] 4) prayer [Halacha 8], 5) Speech and other actions [Halachas 9-10] 6) using the bathroom [Halacha 9], are all under discussion as to whether they are considered a removal of the mind.
- Shinuiy Makom: Changing locations, such as going from one room to another, or inside to out and vice a versa may require one to repeat the before blessing. Due to the length of this topic, a full chapter has been dedicated to it and will be discussed in Chapter 20!
- Ikkul: If enough time has passed for one to digest the food eaten, then he may be required to repeat the before blessing if he decides to further eat. This matter is relevant to both the before and after blessing, and will be discussed in chapter 21 which is the chapter dealing with the laws of after blessings.
| Reason | Description | Relevant Halacha/Chapter |
| Speaking and other intervals | Not considered a Hefsek unless between blessing and initial eating | Chapter 7 Halacha 3-4, Halacha 7-8 |
| Hesech Hadas – Resolve to not eat (Nimlach) | May require repetition if one reconsiders eating | Halacha 2 |
| Hesech Hadas – After blessing recited | Considered Hesech Hadas, requires repetition | Halacha 4-5 |
| Hesech Hadas – Sleeping | Under discussion if considered removal of mind | Halacha 7 |
| Hesech Hadas – Prayer | Under discussion if considered removal of mind | Halacha 8 |
| Hesech Hadas – Speech and other actions | Under discussion if considered removal of mind | Halacha 9-10 |
| Hesech Hadas – Using the bathroom | Under discussion if considered removal of mind | Halacha 9 |
| Shinuiy Makom (Changing location) | May require repetition, e.g., going from one room to another | Chapter 20 |
| Ikkul (Time to digest) | If enough time has passed to digest, may require repetition | Chapter 21 |
| Term | Definition and Implication |
| Hesech Hadas | Removal of the mind from eating, potentially requiring blessing repetition |
| Nimlach | Deciding to stop eating and then changing one’s mind |
| Hefsek | Interruption that may require repeating blessings |
| Shiur Ikkul | Time threshold indicating digestion, affecting blessing validity |
| Shinas Keva | Standard sleep requiring blessing repetition |
