From the Rav’s Desk – Q&A’s on burial and more

The cremated ashes of a Jew do not require burial. If they are buried, they are not to be buried in the regular part of the cemetery [not even in the non-Shomer Shabbos section] and rather they are to be buried outside the cemetery fence.[1]

[1] Seridei Eish 2:123; Igros Moshe Y.D. 3:147; Nitei Gavriel ibid; See Gesher Hachaim 16:7

Yes, as it does not give off purity to Kohanim.

Background:

Does the ash of a corpse give off Tuma?[1] Many Poskim[2] rule that the ash of a corpse [which has no bone fragments remaining] does not give off impurity and hence there is no prohibition for a Kohen to be in contact with the ash or be in the same room as it. [Thus, a Kohen may enter into a room that contains the cremated remains of a person and may even hold the jar or ash in his hand.[3] This applies whether the ashes belong to a Jewish corpse or gentile corpse.] However, other Poskim[4] rule that the ash of a corpse does give off impurity and it is hence forbidden for a Kohen to defile himself to it.[5] Practically, one may certainly be lenient regarding entering Tumas Ohel to enter a room that contains the ash of a corpse[6], and those who are lenient to even touch and move the ash have upon him to rely as so is the main opinion in the Poskim. [This question especially arose after the Holocaust in which millions of Jews were burned in the crematorium, and the collective ashes were later taken and buried and Kohanim who had loved ones who were killed and burned asked if they can visit the burial site of the ash, the vast majority of Poskim concluded that it is allowed.[7]]

[1] See Hamiaseif 9:17-13; Anei Shoham Inyanei Hageluyos Yimei Hazam p. 436; Sefer Emek Habacha 2; Chayeh Olam; Koveitz Beis Yisrael 211 p. 124; Dibros Eliyahu 8:74

[2] Sheilas Yaavetz 2:169, brought in Pischeiy Teshuvah Y.D. 369:2; Rambam Tumas Meis 3:10 “The flesh of a corpse which has disintegrated and become like flour is pure and so too the ash of a corpse is pure”; Chachamim in Mishneh Ohalos 2:2; Taam Vadaas; Milameid Lehoil Y.D. 2:114 in name of Ramban, Rashba, Ran and Ritva; Seridei Eish 1:181; Chelkas Yaakov Y.D. 217; Minchas Yitzchak 1:30

[3] Cremated bodies are burnt at temperatures between 1400-1800 Fahrenheit for about 2-2.5 hours. The bones are reduced to calcified matter which are later crushed and processed, being reduced to ash like particles. Thus, in a jar containing the cremated remains of a person there are no remaining body particles that pose a Halachic issue for a Kohen regarding the laws of impurity.

[4] Rebbe Eliezer in the Mishneh ibid; Lechem Hapanim 364; Shut Harashbash 610; Tosafus Nida 27b; Paneiach Raza Parshas Korach; Shevet Shimon Chidushei Sugyos

[5] The reason: Rebbe Eliezer in the Mishneh ibid holds that the ash of a corpse does give Tuma. Furthermore, some Poskim rule that even according to Chachamim, the ash of a corpse is only considered to not give off impurity if it was burned while the person was still alive as it never had an opportunity to give off impurity, however, if it was burned after death, then since it gave off impurity prior to the burning, it’s ashes remain impure and may not be touched by a Kohen. [Shevet Shimon Chidushei Sugyos] Furthermore, some Poskim rule that ash of a corpse always gives off impurity being that it contains the Luz bone which is not able to be destroyed and from which the resurrection will occur and hence it is forbidden for a Kohen to defile himself to it. [Beis Yisrael p. 33, based on Lechem Hapanim 364] Practically, however, the Poskim negate the above claims, as it is clear from the wording of the Rambam ibid that ash never gives off impurity even if the corpse was burned after death as he previously states that flesh which disintegrates and becomes like flour is pure. Likewise, it is clear from the Talmud that the Luz bone does not give off impurity. [Sheilas Yaavetz ibid]

[6] Chelkas Yaakov Y.D. 217; Dibros Eliyahu ibid

[7] See Hamiaseif 9:17-13; Anei Shoham Inyanei Hageluyos Yimei Hazam p. 436; Sefer Emek Habacha 2; Chayeh Olam; Koveitz Beis Yisrael 211 p. 124

This depends on the burial society and the governing rules that they follow. Whatever the case, they may not bury the ashes in a regular part of the cemetery. In Israel, the Chief rabbinate has a policy that they do not bury the cremated ashes of any individual. [Heard from Rav Yaakov Roza, Chief Rabbi of the Chevra Kadish in Israel] This is done in order to discourage people from cremating their loved ones.

If one does not have a sense of smell:[1]

One who does not have the sense of smell [whether due to being born this way or due to a cold or stuffed nose[2]] may not say the blessing of Besamim in Havdalah even if there are other adults fulfilling their obligation with hearing his Havdalah.[3] If however there are also children who have reached the age of Chinuch fulfilling their obligation with hearing his Havdalah, then he may say the blessing on their behalf and have them smell it. [Some write that even when one does not have a sense of smell it is proper for him to try smelling the Besamim after the blessing is said by others, or on behalf of children, as perhaps his soul feels the smell.[4]]

_______________________________________

[1] Admur 297:7

[2] See Kaf Hachaim 297:34; Halachos Ketanos 2:183

[3] This applies even if the adults do not know how to say the blessings themselves, as all blessings of Birchas Hanehnin may only be said for another person if the person who is saying the blessing is also benefiting from it, and the blessing of Besamim on Motzei Shabbos is included within the blessings of Birchas Hanehnin.

This is thus not similar to the blessing of Hagafen said by Kiddush of which we allow one to say this blessing for another person even if he himself will not be drinking the wine, as the wine of Kiddush is not being brought because of one’s benefit from it but rather due to the institution of the Sages to say Kiddush over wine. [Hence it is similar to Birchas Hamitzvos which one can say for another person even if he himself has already done the Mitzvah.] However Besamim on Motzei Shabbos, despite it also being accustomed due to the Sages, it was only accustomed in order to benefit the person to comfort his soul which is saddened due to the leave of Shabbos, and hence its blessing is similar to any other blessing over foods and the like. [Admur ibid based on Taz 8]

Other Opinions: Rama 297:5 rules one may say the blessing of Besamim for those adults who do not know to say it themselves.

[4] Kaf Hachaim 297:36

From the Rav’s Desk – Q&A’s on burial and more

Post Views: 546 Must one bury the ash that remains after cremation if a Jew was cremated Chas Veshalom? The cremated ashes of a Jew do not require burial. If they are buried, they are not to be buried in the regular part of the cemetery [not even in the

Read More »

From the Rav’s Desk – Q&A’s on Kashrus & More

Post Views: 785 How to Kasher a dairy vessel that became Treif due to absorption of meat, or vice a versa? Question: I accidentally used a clean meat baking pan to bake dairy pizza in my dairy oven. Is it possible for me to kosher my baking pan with Hagala

Read More »

From the Rav’s Desk – Q&A’s on Davening and more

Post Views: 609 Forgot Mashiv Haruach and remembered right away Question: [Monday, 15th Mar Cheshvan, 5781] If one forgot to say Mashiv Haruach Umorid Hageshem, and remembered at the end of the blessing prior to saying Hashem’s name. Should he go back and say it, should he say it then, or she

Read More »

From the Rav’s Desk – Q&A’s on Yom Tov

Post Views: 204 May one distribute the charity for Yizkor already before Yom Tov? Yes. Some are accustomed even initially to already distribute the charity before Yom Tov, and then say in the Nussach “As I have given.”[1]] __________________________ [1] Gesher Hachaim 31:2-3; Nitei Gavriel 79:29 What comes first; Yizkor

Read More »

About The Author

Leave A Comment?

You must be logged in to post a comment.