Forgot to say Ledavid by Mincha
- Question:
I forgot to say Ledavid by Mincha, may I make it up by Maariv?
Answer:
Seemingly it is better not to do so. However, one who does so have upon whom to rely.
The reason: We indeed find that some are accustomed even initially to say Ledavid at night, and so is the recorded Minhag Ashkenaz. Practically, however, most Poskim rule it is to be said by Mincha, which would enter its recital by Maariv into a question of saying Tehillim at night, which is avoided. Thus, it would seem that one should not make it up at night in expense of transgressing the adherence of avoiding saying Tehillim at night which is not part of the Seder Tefila. However, one who does so under the argument that it is considered Seder Tefila for some Jews seemingly has upon whom to rely.
Sources: Alef Hamagen 581:6; Divrei Malkiel 6:23-2; Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 128:2; Siddur Admur; M”B 581:2; Siddur Beis Yaavetz-additions of the editor
Other Articles
From the Rav’s Desk: Shaalos Veteshuvos on Bikurim and more
Post Views: 140 Bikurim today Bikurim today Question: Does the Mitzvah of Bikurim exist today and what if someone designated a first fruit on his tree as Bikurim? We learned about Bikurim this past week in class and my teacher showed us a picture of a tree in her house
From the Rav’s Desk: Shaalos Veteshuvos on Rosh Hashanah
Post Views: 760 Forgot to say Ledavid by Mincha Forgot to say Ledavid by Mincha Question: I forgot to say Ledavid by Mincha, may I make it up by Maariv? Answer: Seemingly it is better not to do so. However, one who does so have upon whom to rely.
From the Rav’s Desk: Shaalos Veteshuvos on Tefillin, Mezuzos & More
Post Views: 895 May one say Daven Shacharis without a Tallis Gadol if none is available? May one say Daven Shacharis without a Tallis Gadol if none is available? Question: May one say Daven without a Tallis Gadol? I had my tefillin checked and by the time I picked them
From the Rav’s Desk: Shaalos Veteshuvos on Peyos & More
Post Views: 119 Placing the Peyos behind or covering ears Placing the Peyos behind or covering ears:[1] A person should avoid covering his ears with his Peyos during Shemoneh Esrei and throughout Davening. [Some[2] learn that one is to be particular in this throughout the day and not just during
From the Rav’s Desk: Walking behind one’s Rebbe & More
Post Views: 155 Walking behind one’s Rebbe Question: Is it permitted for one to walk behind his Rebbe? Answer: It is forbidden for one to walk to the side of ones Rebbe as this appears as if one views himself equal to his Rebbe and he is considered an
From the Ravs Desk: Q&A on Fish, feeding employees and an angry Get
Post Views: 128 Eating Live Fish Question: I have a theoretical question regarding the kashrus of fish. May one eat a live fish? Does it have a prohibition of Eiver Min Hachaiy? Answer: While the prohibition of Eiver Min Hachaiy does not apply to live fish and hence it
Leave A Comment?
You must be logged in to post a comment.