This article is an excerpt from our Sefer

Chapter 5: Cases of prohibition and avoidance [1]
|
Important note – Niddah laws: Obviously, intimacy is only permitted when one’s wife has purified herself from her Niddah state through immersion in a Kosher Mikveh. It is beyond the scope of this Sefer to discuss the laws of Niddah and when a woman is deemed impure, hence prohibiting relations. Accordingly, the frequencies of intimacy discussed in this chapter are bound by all the laws of Niddah, and solely applicable when the woman is deemed pure according to Halacha.
|
1. Bnei Teisha Midos-Force; angry; mourning; other woman; drunk; divorce; sleeping; brazen: [2]
A. The general rule:
The Sages related nine different situations for which marital relations are to be abstained from [and is forbidden[3]]. Lack of doing so can lead to having rebellious children [who have evil souls created from that sinful union[4] or have a rebellious husband[5]] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as the verse states, “I will create from amongst you those who rebel and sin against Me.” These restrictions are known as, “Bnei Teisha Midos,” and refer to the children born from unions of the following nine situations. [Alternatively, it refers to the husband and wife who had relations under such circumstances.[6]]
Pregnant, nursing or past menopause:[7] These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, using a contraceptive, or has had her womb removed].
Peru Urevu:[8] These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah.
The list of Bnei Teisha Midos:
- Bnei Annusa: Intercourse that is done against the will of the wife or done begrudgingly. [See Halacha B]
- Bnei Senua: Intercourse that is done while the couple is angry with each other. [See Halacha D]
- Bnei Niduiy: Intercourse that is done while one of the spouses is in excommunication or Aveilus. [See Halacha F]
- Bnei Temura: Intercourse that is done with intention for one wife while sleeping with another wife. [See Halacha G]
- Bnei Moredes: Intercourse that is done with a rebellious wife who does not desire to remain married. [See Halacha H]
- Bnei Shichrus: Intercourse that is done while under the influence of alcohol. [See Halacha I]
- Bnei Irbuvya: Intercourse that is done while thinking of another man or woman. [See Halacha G]
- Bnei Gerushas Haleiv: Intercourse that is done while he has intent to divorce her. [See Halacha J]
- Bnei Chatzufa: Intercourse that is done after she asks for relations in a brazen manner. [See Halacha K]
|
The main theme of the Bnei Teishe Midos – The requirement of love and passion in intimacy: After contemplating all of the Bnei Tishe Midos restrictions, one can conclude that the common denominator is that the intimacy must be done with mutual love and desire between the couple, and when there are moods or situations which are contrary to these feelings of love, or make them absent, then intimacy is forbidden. From here we can learn the great emphasis, according to Halacha and Jewish philosophy, on the couple being in a loving and passionate relationship with each other. The common misconception that Torah views intercourse as a dry method of procreation cannot be further than the truth, and indeed, dry and emotionless intimacy for the mere sake of procreation is in fact forbidden as understood from the negations of the Bnei Tishe Midos.
|
B. #1 Bnei Annusa – Against will of wife or done begrudgingly: [9]
One may not have relations with his wife against her will [such as if she is upset with him[10] or is exhausted, and therefore does not desire intimacy]. [This prohibition applies even if he does not force himself upon her and actually rape her, but simply gets her to begrudgingly acquiesce to the relations.[11] Thus, a husband must appease and stimulate his wife prior to relations, and only then may they engage in intercourse.[12] Likewise, a husband must avoid overburdening his wife to have intimacy with him too often when he knows that it will be done begrudgingly.[13] Having intercourse against the will of one’s wife, or even begrudgingly, can cause that one have improper children born to him[14] who may become rebellious and go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos[15] and might be born with blemishes.[16] Having intercourse against her will, mystically, transgresses the prohibition of Giluiy Arayos.[17] The Divine presence does not reside with the intimacy when it is against the will of the wife.[18]] *See Chapter 7 Halacha 5 for the full laws and details of Piyus affection prior to intercourse.
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
|
Q&A If the husband attempts to appease his wife, must she acquiesce to his appeasement and his request for intimacy? As understood from the Rambam’s[19] directives, it is proper for the wife to be open to appeasement and try to reach a point that she can be open and willing to consent to her husband’s desire.
Does the above prohibition, of doing so against her will, only refer to actual intercourse or to any sexual act? The prohibition certainly extends to all actions done during the actual intercourse, such as positions during intercourse and the like, that it may not be done against her will.[20] Regarding other acts which lead up to the intercourse, while certainly it should not be done against her will, it requires further analysis if this is included in the severity of Bnei Anussa.[21]
May one have intimacy a second time in a row against the will, or with begrudging consent, of the wife?[22] No. Although having intimacy twice consecutively is beneficial for having male children,[23] nevertheless, it may only be done with full consent of the wife and if she is appeased. [However, so long as he has yet to separate from her, he may continue with a second ejaculation.[24]]
If one desires to sanctify himself during intimacy and lessen the amount of hugging, kissing and other touch, may he do so against the will of his wife?[25] If this will cause his wife to be upset with him during the intimacy, then it is forbidden.
May the wife have intercourse with the husband if it is against his will?[26] The husband is also required to desire the intimacy. Hence, if it is against his will, or he is doing it begrudgingly, then it is not allowed.[27] Thus, if the husband is exhausted and is intimate simply to fulfill the Mitzvah of Onah and keep her happy, even though he does not currently desire her at all, then it falls under the status of Bnei Teisha Midos.[28]
If a wife does not desire intimacy with her husband, even after appeasement, may he nevertheless have intercourse with her?[29] No, rather he is to wait for another time when she will desire to be intimate.[30] If, however, this is a chronic situation, in which the wife never desires intimacy, even after appeasement, then some Poskim[31] rule that he may be intimate with her even if she acquiesces begrudgingly. Other Poskim,[32] however, rule that he may never be lenient, even in such a case, and they hence must seek counsel and intervention.
May a husband have intercourse with his wife against her will for the sake of fulfilling the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu? No, even when the intent of the intercourse is to impregnate his wife and fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu, he may not do so against her will. Nonetheless, he is obligated to try to appease her until she acquiesces to the intimacy in order to fulfill the Mitzvah.
|
|
The need for love and passion and the negation of depression, laziness, and disinterest:[33] During intimacy, the couple must be filled with true love, joy, and passion for each other; through doing so, they will merit to have children who are righteous and scholarly. Thus, all feelings of laziness, depression, fear, panic or anger must be dispelled prior to engaging in intimacy. Being in a state of depression, fear, anger or panic during intimacy can effect that the born child will also carry these negative traits and be a dark and depressed individual, or be very aggressive and get into fights often, or be very dull-headed.[34] Thus, if one sees that their spouse is engaged in these kinds of moods, then he is to appease her/him and try to console them and make them feel better so they can have a proper and desirable state of intimacy. All of the below is relevant to all Jews, and especially to Torah scholars.[35] [Thus, the perspective that Judaism looks at intimacy as a dry act of procreation, and that the righteous and pious should do so with no feeling, is very distanced from the true Jewish philosophy that it must involve feeling and passion.]
Being romantic and telling the spouse of one’s love for them: If the wife sees that her husband is saddened about something, she should try to console him and tell him how much she loves him and cherishes him, and give him words of praise and encouragement.[36] The same applies vice versa, for the husband to the wife.
|
C. #1b When she is sleeping: [37]
One may not have relations with his wife while she is sleeping [and one who does so is considered to transgress having relations with her against her will[38]]. [Seemingly, this applies even if she agrees.[39]]
If she is only half asleep:[40] If she is only half asleep, there is no prohibition to have intimacy with her. [Nonetheless, one is not encouraged to do so, as brought below.[41]]
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
|
Intimacy when tired, exhausted, or sleepy:[42] During intimacy, the couple must be filled with true love, joy, and passion for each other, as stated above. Thus, all feelings of tiredness and sleepiness must be dispelled prior to engaging in intimacy. Accordingly, if the husband is tired or sleepy and is therefore having difficulty getting himself into the mood for desiring his wife, he should abstain from the intimacy until he can properly arouse himself, as intimacy should not take place while there is disinterest. He should speak with his wife using words that arouse his love and lust for her, as well as do other necessary actions for his love to be aroused. Not to wait until one is tired and exhausted: Due to the above, it is critical for the intimacy and scheduled intercourse to take place at a time that both the husband and the wife are alert and awake and not tired with exhaustion. Therefore, it is best for it to be scheduled earlier on in the night, or after taking a nap, or drinking a caffeinated beverage for the sake of raising the quality of their experience. Intimacy under exhaustion usually diminishes the interest, desire and passion needed for the intimacy and causes laziness, which prevents the couple from taking the time to progress in building the feelings and emotions necessary for intimacy to happen.
|
D. #2a Bnei Senuah-Angry with each other or in a state of argument or fighting: [43]
It is forbidden to have relations with one’s wife if he became angry with her until he appeases her. [The same applies if they got into an emotional argument or fight.[44]] One may talk with his wife during preparation of intercourse in order to appease her.[45] Lack of doing so can lead to having rebellious children [created from that sinful union, or have rebellious husbands] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A.
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
See Q&A in section in E for questions related to this subject!
E. #2b Bnei Senuah-Wife is despised by husband or vice versa: [46]
One may not have relations with his wife if he despises her at the time of the intercourse. [This applies even if he generally loves her, but is upset with her at that moment, as explained above. If, however, he generally despises her, but is now in love with her, then it may be done.[47] The same restriction applies if the wife despises him.[48]] Lack of guarding the above [considers their intimacy to be promiscuous[49] and] can lead to having rebellious children [created from that sinful union, or have rebellious husbands] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A.[50] [Children born from such a union are Rabbinically considered as spiritual Mamzeirim.[51]]
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
|
Bnei Meriva-A couple who is always fighting and bickering:[52] If a couple is always fighting to the point that they are in a constant state of being upset with each other, even during intimacy, then it is forbidden to be intimate until they settle their issues and can put it behind them. If they have intimacy while still in their state of fighting, then it is considered Biyas Zenus, a promiscuous relation, and causes the children born from such unions to be rebellious, as stated above in A. [If, however, they manage to arouse true love for each other during the session of intimacy, then it is permitted, as explained in E regarding Bnei Senuah. Practically, a couple who have constant long-term issues with each other, and are no longer in a state of love due to it, must take measures to fix the issues in order so that they can continue being loving and intimate, and have spiritually healthy children born to them. If necessary, they should speak with a Rav and/or marriage counselor and consider birth control, or even separation if all efforts to make peace between them are useless, in order to not have improper children born to them.[53] The philosophy that some people have, in which they advise having children anyways and that the children will repair the relationship, is often misguided as well as problematic according to Halacha, as it creates children defined as Bnei Meriva and Bnei Senua which can become spiritually unhealthy children.]
Placing effort to have a peaceful home-Shalom Bayis:[54] Due to the above prohibition of having intimacy in a state of anger or being upset at each other, the couple is to place maximum effort, especially near the scheduled times of intimacy, in being extra caring and loving to each other in order for the intimacy to be with true love and passion, and not with reluctance in any way. Q&A on D-E If the couple got into a disagreement or argument over a certain matter, must the matter be settled prior to intercourse or can they schedule to further discuss it later on?[55] So long as the matter has been put to rest until a further discussion, and they have returned to feelings of love for each other, they may resume with intimacy.
Who has the main responsibility to bring appeasement if there is an argument between the couple?[56] The main responsibility is on the shoulders of the husband, to actively find a peaceful solution to their differences and appease his wife to have intimacy with no hard feelings. This applies even if it is the husband who is angry at something that his wife did or did not do. [This does not mean that the wife is always correct and the husband always incorrect, but rather that even when the husband is in the right, he must take the leading role in attempting to bring the matter to a peaceful solution. This can be learned from Moshe Rabbeinu who approached Dasan and Avirum in attempt to calm the fires of discord, even though most certainly they were the guilty party in their case.]
If the husband or wife is angry at another person or event, that has nothing to do with their spouse, may they have intimacy?[57] They should not be intimate until the anger has subsided, even if the anger is not related at all to the spouse. The reason for this is because intimacy needs to be done in a mood of love and joy, while lack of such feelings being present can affect the child in a negative way.
If a husband is not attracted to his wife [or vice versa] and does not feel in love with her, may he be intimate with her?[58] So long as the husband does not despise his wife and is able to arouse feelings of love and desire during the actual intimacy, then it is permitted for them to engage in intimacy, and the children of such intimacy are not defined as Bnei Senua.[59] [Thus, a newlywed couple may engage in intimacy, even if they have yet to build a real attraction or love for each other, as is common in the Chassidic world for couples to marry after one short meeting.] Nonetheless, initially a man is not to marry a woman who he has no physical attraction to, as the intimacy must take place with real love and passion, and not having any attraction to one’s wife can lead to him despising her even during intimacy.[60] Furthermore, even if the couple initially loved and were attracted to each other, if they see that their love and relationship has become stale, they need to brainstorm ways to rekindle it.
|
F. #3 Bnei Niduiy-Excommunication or Aveilus: [61]
One may not have relations with his wife if he [or his wife[62]] is in excommunication. [The same applies if one of them is sitting Shiva, as explained in Chapter 4 Halacha 4.[63]] Lack of guarding the above can lead to having rebellious children [created from that sinful union, or have rebellious husbands] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A.
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
|
Q&A If the husband r”l consciously performed Zera Levatala using his hand [i.e. masturbation] and is thus in Niduiy, may he be intimate with his wife? Some Poskim[65] rule that one who performs Zera Levatala is considered to be in automatic Niduiy [until he does Teshuvah[66]]. Accordingly, such a person must repent prior to being intimate with his wife, in order so that the intimacy not be defined as Bnei Niduiy.[67]
If the husband consciously brings himself to an erection during times that intimacy will not take place [i.e. she is a Niddah], is he considered to be in Niduiy? Some Poskim[68] rule that although such a person is considered fit to be put into Niduiy, they are not actually considered to be in Niduiy unless it ch”v leads to Zera Levatala, as explained above.
|
G. #4-5 Bnei Temura and Irbuvya-Thinking of another man or woman: [69]
One may not think of another woman during marital relations. This applies even if they are both his wives[70] [and certainly if he thinks of a woman who is not his wife]. [The children born from such a union are close to being considered Mamzeirim.[71]] It causes one to have rebellious children [or to have rebellious husbands] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A.[72] [On the other hand, focusing on one’s wife during intimacy causes the children to be born Tzadikim.[73] Likewise, the wife may not think of another man during intercourse, and if she does so, her children become mute r”l.[74] It is most severe if both the husband and wife are thinking of other people.[75]]
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
|
The spiritual dangers to the child by having intercourse while thinking of another woman:[76] One who thinks of another woman, or gentile woman, while having intimacy with his wife, causes that she too thinks of him when she is with her gentile husband. This has the spiritual power to cause the souls to be switched and have a heretic be born from the union of the Jewish couple and have a future convert born from the union of the gentile couple. This is the mystical meaning behind Bnei Temurah, as the souls of the children become switched. There is nothing that causes greater damage above in heaven than the forbidden thoughts which one has during intimacy. [Thus, spiritually, such a child is considered like a Mamzer, as stated above.]
Sanctifying one’s thoughts throughout the day of scheduled intimacy:[77] Due to the above, it is very important that on a day scheduled for intimacy, the couple be extra careful to guard their minds and not entertain any forbidden thoughts.
Q&A If the thought of another woman [or man for the wife] momentarily entered one’s mind during intimacy, must they stop?[78] No, so long as he pushes it away from his mind right away. The above prohibition only applies if one consciously entertains the thought of another person, as the Torah was not given to angels, and one cannot prevent momentary thoughts. If, however, one begins to dwell on the thought, then intimacy is forbidden until he can clear his mind.
If a man became aroused due to another woman, may he have intimacy with his wife in order to calm his lust? Yes,[79] and so has been done by the greatest of Sages,[80] and is one of the spiritual benefits of being married, that one has, “bread in his basket,”[81] and is able to be with his wife in order to calm his lustful thoughts and passions and abstain from sin. Nonetheless, obviously, it is forbidden for him to think of the other woman during the intimacy. The intent is simply that he can be intimate with his wife and desire her, in order to release his general aroused lust, not that he may think of the other woman while he is with his wife.
One who woke up with an erection:[82] If one wakes up with an erection [such as due to an erotic dream[83]], he is to be very careful to not have intercourse at that time with that erection, Chas Veshalom. If he does so, the children will be blemished.[84] This applies even if his wife is already pregnant, as it nevertheless causes evil spirits to be created. The Zohar[85] states that an erection upon waking up comes from the angel of lust, called Na’ama/Lilis, and if one has a child from its desire, then Lilis will try to harm the child every Rosh Chodesh. [Rather, he is to wait for the erection to die down, and he may then re-arouse it for holy purposes.[86] A known Segula for reducing the excitement and killing the erection is to immediately go face down onto the ground or bed in a push-up position, and press the fingers of both his hands and toes into the ground.[87] If he cannot get the erection to die down, and has reached a state of excitement in which he fears that if he does not immediately have intercourse it will cause him to ejaculate in vain [Zera Levatala], then he is to have intercourse to save himself from this more severe sin.[88]]
Roll playing: Roll playing does not transgress the prohibition of Bnei Temurah, so long as one’s mind is only on their spouse, even though they use different names or titles.[89] Nonetheless, it is certainly not a refined or proper thing to do, and can lead to greater sin, and is hence not to be done unless it is a time of great need.[90]
|
|
Zivug Sheiyni & couples who have had previous relationships:[91] Husbands or wives who have had previous relationships, such as a widow or divorcee who remarried, or one who became religious only later on in life, must be careful not to think of any other relationships during intimacy. They are not to compare their spouses to their previous relationships. To help facilitate this, they are to avoid living in the same neighborhood as their previous partner, in order to avoid seeing each other.[92] Likewise, they should get rid of any pictures they have of their previous partner, even if it is her previous husband who passed away.[93]
|
H. #6 Bnei Moredes-Rebellious wife who desires divorce: [94]
One may not have relations with his wife if she does not desire to be married to him [and says I do not desire you as a husband[95]]. [This applies even if he manages to temporarily appease her during the intercourse and it is not done against her will.[96] If, however, he appeases her to the point that she regrets her previous words and desires to remain married, then it is valid.[97]] Lack of guarding the above [is considered a promiscuous relationship[98] and] can lead to having rebellious children [created from that sinful union, or rebellious husbands] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A.
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
I. #7 Bnei Shichrus-Drunk: [99]
One may not have relations with his wife if either of them[100] are drunk.[101] [This applies when one of them drank alcohol to the point that their mind became fuzzy and they cannot think straight.[102] However, prior to reaching this state of drunkenness intimacy is permitted, even if they drank a Revi’is or more.[103] One must especially beware of this matter on Purim, or any other holiday or event, in which one consumes a lot of alcohol.[104] Thus, if Mikveh night occurs on the night of the Seder, one should manage his alcohol intake when drinking the four cups. Likewise, a Chasan by his wedding should not drink too much.] Lack of guarding the above [considers the intimacy as promiscuous[105] and] can lead to having rebellious children [created from that sinful union, or rebellious husbands] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A. [Children born from such a union can become alcoholics in their lifetime.[106]]
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
J. #8 Bnei Gerushas Haleiv-If he plans to divorce her: [107]
One may not have relations with his wife if he intends to divorce her [in the near future[108]]. This applies even if he does not hate her [but rather still loves her, and is divorcing her against his will, such as due to Halachic reasons[109]].[110] [This applies even today, even though one cannot divorce his wife against her will.[111]] Furthermore, some Poskim[112] learn that it is forbidden for them to even live together in such a state, even without intercourse. Lack of guarding the above can lead to having rebellious children [created from that sinful union, or to having a rebellious husband] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A.[113]
Informed wife of decision: Some Poskim[114] rule that the above prohibition only applies if the wife is unaware of the impending divorce, however, if the wife is aware, then it is permitted for them to live together and have intercourse and doing so does not contain any prohibition at all.[115] Other Poskim,[116] however, suggest that the prohibition of intimacy applies even in such a case [due to the prohibition of Gerushas Haleiv[117]]. Nonetheless, even according to the stringent approach, they may continue to live together in the same home and have her serve him, if she is aware of the intent to divorce.[118]
Deliberating divorce:[119] If he is debating whether to divorce her, but has yet to make a final decision, then he may continue to have relations with her, unless there are Halachic reasons that validate such a divorce, such as infidelity, in which case they may not be intimate.
Pregnant or nursing or past menopause: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above. [However, if one intends, in the event that his wife becomes pregnant, to not get divorced, then it is permitted to be intimate, even if he plans to divorce her if she does not become pregnant.[120]]
|
Q&A If a couple decides to divorce after their kids are grown up or married off, may they engage in intimacy?[121] If a husband, wife, or couple is waiting to divorce until all their kids are married, then they may have intimacy until the time for divorce has arrived.
If one decides to divorce his wife only if certain conditions materialize, may they be intimate?[122] Yes. So long as the conditions for divorce have yet to materialize it is permitted to engage in intimacy.
If one who decided to divorce his wife agrees to enter a trial period of Shalom Bayis to try to make things work, may they be intimate?[123] Yes.
|
K. #9 Bnei Chatzufa-Asking for relations in a brazen manner: [124]
One may not have relations with his wife if she demands it from him in a brazen manner, similar to a harlot. [If she does this constantly without heeding her husband’s warnings, then he is required to divorce her, so long as she refuses to repent.[125]] However, one may do so if his wife modestly entices him through dressing seductively [hinting to him in her speech,[126] or hugging and kissing him,[127] or lying on his bed seductively[128]], and on the contrary, he will have good children from this union.[129] [Furthermore, if his wife shows that she desires him in one of the above permitted ways, then he is obligated to be intimate with her, as explained in chapter 2 Halacha 3A.] Lack of guarding the above can lead to having [brazen[130] and] rebellious children [created from that sinful union, or rebellious husbands] who go off the path of Torah and Mitzvos, as stated in A.
Pregnancy or nursing: These restrictions apply even if one’s wife is currently pregnant, or is past menopause [or is nursing, or using a contraceptive], as stated in the introduction above.
Peru Urevu: These restrictions apply even if one has yet to fulfill the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu and is having intimacy for the sake of the Mitzvah, as stated in the introduction above.
|
Q&A What are examples of permitted terms that the wife may use to get her husband to be intimate with her?[131] She may use any words that hint towards intimacy, so long as they are free of any explicit reference to it. Thus, while certainly she may not say “Let’s have sex,” and the like, she may say, “do you want to come to bed with me,” and the like.
What should a husband do if his wife is accustomed to verbally demand intimacy?[132] He should try to preempt her and talk to her about it first.
How long after one’s wife brazenly asks for intercourse must one wait prior to being intimate?[133] One must wait until the matter is put behind them and he then re-desires the intimacy on his own, or his wife asks for it in a valid manner.
|
2. When feeling hungry or satiated: [134]
[Due to medical reasons,[135] as well as due to negative effects on a child born from such a union] one is not to have intercourse when he [or she] is hungry or satiated [right after a meal].[136] Rather, one is to do so [some time] after eating, when the food has already begun to be digested [half-way to the point that he is no longer full, but also, not yet hungry[137]]. [This applies to both the husband and the wife.[138] This applies even if one’s wife cannot currently conceive, such as during pregnancy, and it most certainly applies if there is possibility of conception.[139] Seemingly, this adherence is not a letter of the law obligation, but rather a medical and practical advisory.]
|
Eating a proper diet prior to intimacy:[140] Being that the seed of man is developed from the foods which he eats, it is proper that one be careful to eat light and healthy foods on the day of intimacy, and that he does not overeat. Eating coarse foods will affect the quality of the seed and can cause the children to carry damaging character traits. Accordingly, the foods that one eats on the day of intimacy should also be regulated, this is included in the Mitzvah of Kedusha during Tashmish. Certainly, one who accidentally ate a non-Kosher food should not have intercourse on that day due to this reason, as the sperm created from such foods will be impure and contain evil tendencies. It is for this reason that the laws of childbirth brought in the beginning of Parshas Tazria follows the laws of Kashrus found in the end of Parshas Kedoshim.[141]
|
3. After leaving the bathroom: [142]
One who leaves a bathroom is not to have marital relations [for a certain period of time, as explained next].[143] [While this adherence especially applies if one can become pregnant from the intimacy, or is already pregnant, nonetheless, it should be followed at all times even if the wife cannot become pregnant and is past menopause.[144] This adherence applies to both the husband and the wife, and thus, if either one used the bathroom, the wait time listed below is to be observed prior to intercourse.[145] This adherence applies even if one did not use the bathroom at all, but simply entered it.[146] This, however, only applies to an actual bathroom, and hence if one went to the bathroom in an open area, such as a field, it does not apply, and no delay is required.[147]]
How much time to wait: Some Poskim[148] write that intercourse is to be avoided for that entire hour. Others,[149] however, rule that one only needs to wait the period of half a Mil, which is 12 or even 9 minutes.[150] Practically, one is to wait 12, and at the very least 9, minutes after using the bathroom prior to intercourse. [This refers to actual intercourse. However, there is no need at all to delay engaging in hugging, kissing and the like until the passing of this time period.]
|
Q&A After a shower, must one wait a minimum of nine minutes prior to intercourse?[151] No. The above adherence applies specifically to a bathroom. Nonetheless, if one’s shower is found in the same room as one’s toilet, as is common in many homes, then one is to wait nine minutes, as stated above.
Is one to wait a minimum of nine minutes prior to intercourse if only his hand entered into the bathroom, such as to close the door? Some Poskim[152] rule one is to do so. However, other Poskim[153] rule that regarding today’s bathrooms one may be lenient.
|
4. After excessive bathing, spa treatment or Jacuzzi: [154]
One is not to have relations on a day of [excessive[155]] bathing [such as during a spa treatment in which one spent excessive time in a jacuzzi, steam room or sauna]. [Accordingly, some Poskim[156] rule that one should not bathe his entire body in hot water on Erev Shabbos. Other Poskim,[157] however, rule that the above restriction is due to health reasons, however, according to Halacha it remains permitted to have relations even on the day of a spa treatment Hence, we find that Torah scholars would have intimacy on Friday night despite having visited the bathhouse on Erev Shabbos. Other Poskim[158] rule that the above restriction only applies in close proximity to the spa treatment. Thus, it is permitted to have intercourse the night before, or the night after, the spa treatment.[159] Practically, one may bathe in hot water on Erev Shabbos, and it is even a Mitzvah to do so, even though he plans to have relations that night.[160] Seemingly, this avoidance of intercourse only applies if the husband had a lengthy spa treatment and does not apply when the wife has had one.]
|
Q&A May one have intimacy after a shower or bath?[161] Yes. The above restriction is only after excessive stay in hot water or steam.
|
5. After bloodletting and blood tests: [162]
One is not to have relations on a day of bloodletting [until he eats something, and his strength returns to him[163]]. [Thus, one is not to have relations after a blood test or blood donation until he eats and regains his strength.[164] Seemingly, this adherence only applies if the husband had a blood test and does not apply when the wife has had one.]
|
Intercourse after recovering from illness:[165] One who has recovered from an illness is to abstain from intercourse until he fully regains his strength. Lack of waiting until a full recovery can lead to relapse. [In all cases of doubt, one is to seek advise from a doctor.] |
6. After travel and/or long walk or workout:
See Chapter 4 Halacha 7.
7. No erection:
[From a medical perspective] one is not to have intercourse unless he has constant strong erections even when he is not thinking of the subject, and it weighs down on his thighs.[166] Nonetheless, this restriction is only due to health reasons, however, according to Halacha it remains permitted to have relations even if one has not reached such a state, such as for the sake of fulfilling the Mitzvah of Onah.[167] [Furthermore, even in the event that one has a natural erection, he is to try to re-arouse himself for the sake of the Mitzvah, and not have intercourse simply due to a natural erection which is due to male hormones.[168]]
8. After bad dream: [169]
Some Poskim[170] rule that one is not to have intimacy after having a bad dream until one fasts for the dream, unless it is the night of Mikveh. Practically, since today people are no longer accustomed to fast after a bad dream, there is no issue to have intimacy after a bad dream.[171]
9. Privacy – The law if there are other people in the room: [172]
Person is awake: It is forbidden to have relations in front of any human, even a child [or slave[173]], who is awake and is old enough to talk. [This applies even at night and if the room is pitch black.[174] This prohibition applies even if the person will not know that the couple is having relations.[175]]
The law if there is a Mechitza between the awake individual and the couple:[176] The above prohibition applies even if one places a Mechitzah that is ten Tefachim high between them.[177] [Some Poskim[178] imply that this applies even if the person will not know that the couple is having relations. Other Poskim,[179] however, rule that it is permitted for the couple to have relations if there is a Kosher Mechitza in front of them and it will not be noticeable to the person there that the couple is having relations. Practically, one may be lenient if he makes a Mechitzah. The Mechitza is to be ten Tefachim high,[180] which is 80 centimeters,[181] and 4 Tefachim wide,[182] which is 32 centimeters. It is to be strong enough so that a common wind cannot knock it down.[183] Thus, if a sheet is used, it must be strongly attached by all its corners.[184] It is forbidden for one to make such a Mechitza on Shabbos, although one may add to an already existing Mechitza.[185]]
The law if the person is sleeping:[186] If the person is sleeping, then one may have relations in the same room. [Some Poskim,[187] however, imply that this only applies if there is a Mechitza. Practically, Lechatchila it is proper to make a Mechitzah, although from the letter of the law it is permitted even without a Mechitza.[188]]
The law if a child is in the room:[189] It is forbidden to have relations in front of a child who is awake and is old enough to talk. [This applies even if he does not understand what the parents are doing, but can repeat what his eyes saw.[190]] If the child is not yet able to talk [enough words to describe the actions of the parents[191]], then one may have relations in that child’s presence.[192] [However, if the child knows how to talk, but does not do so due to weakness or shyness, then it is forbidden to have relations in his presence.[193] Furthermore, even if the child is an infant and cannot talk, it is Midas Chassidus to abstain from having intimacy with the child in the room, if he is still awake.[194] If, however, the child is sleeping, then it is permitted without restriction, as stated above, and even a Mechitza is not necessary. Furthermore, by a baby one may be lenient even if it is only a doubt as to whether he is asleep.[195] Likewise, if the child refuses to go to sleep and lack of intimacy can lead to Zera Levatala, then one is to have intercourse, if the child is not yet able to talk, and is not to be stringent even due to the Midas Chassidus.[196] Likewise, if there is a Mechitza in front of the child, there is no need to be stringent even due to Midas Chassidus, if the child is not yet able to talk, even if he is awake.]
|
Q&A May a couple have relations in the presence of a Shoteh [imbecile]? Some Poskim[197] question if one may have intercourse in the presence of an imbecile, and lean towards permitting doing so.
May a couple have relations in a room if people outside will know what they are doing?[198] Yes. The prohibition only applies if there is someone in their actual room. Nonetheless, they are to try to be as inconspicuous as possible.
|
|
Midas Chassidus – Living creatures in room:[199] From the letter of the law, it is permitted to have intercourse in front of living creatures, such as birds, animal pets, and insects.[200] However, it is an act of piety to not have relations in front of any creature, even a fly. The Talmud[201] states that Abayey would brush away flies from the bed prior to intercourse. Likewise, many sages avoided intercourse in front of rats.[202] This applies even at night and in a dark room. The spiritual reason for why this is done is in order to emphasize one’s absolute nullification during his time of intimacy, and that he is not even like the smallest creature.[203] [Nonetheless, certainly one may not nullify his Onah obligations due to this act of piety.]
The reason that privacy is required during intimacy:[204] Originally, Adam and Chava had intimacy in front of other creatures and this caused the jealousy of the Nachash, and was the cause of the sin of the tree of knowledge. Hence, from then onwards we must be careful to hide the intimacy from all creatures, so the eyes of jealousy do not shine on it.
|
10. Baby on bed: [205]
One may not have intercourse on a bed that a baby is sleeping on, even if the child is less than a year old and is sleeping on the end of the bed. [Some Poskim[206] learn that this prohibition applies whether the child is asleep or awake. Other Poskim,[207] however, rule that it only applies if the child is asleep and does not apply if he is awake.]
The dangers of doing so:[208] One who does so can cause his child to have the Nichfeh [neurological] illness. [This danger applies to both the living child and a child who could be born from this union.]
Child is at the head of the bed:[209] If the child is by the head of the bed, then it is permitted to be done. [This applies whether the child is awake or asleep.[210] However, according to the Zohar, it is implied that it should not be done while the child is awake even if he is by the head of the bed.[211]]
Child is one year old:[212] If the child is more than one year of age, then there is no worry at all of the above issue, and intimacy is permitted even when the child is lying on the bed. [See previous Halacha regarding if the child is awake.[213]]
Placing hand on child:[214] Nonetheless, if one places his hand on the child [during the intercourse] then there is no need for worry.
|
Summary: One may not have intercourse on a bed that a baby is on if the child is less than a year old, and is sleeping on the end of bed. However, if any of the following conditions are fulfilled, then it is permitted to be done: 1. The child is more than a year old. 2. According to some Poskim it does not apply if the baby is awake. 3. The child is by the head of the bed, whether awake or asleep. 4. One places his hand on the child [during the intercourse].
|
11. Nursing child awake: [215]
One who has a nursing child is not to have marital relations while the child is awake. [Some Poskim,[216] however, explain that this is simply good advice and is not an actual prohibition.]
12. Guests – Guest couples having intimacy in the home of a host: [217]
It is forbidden for a guest to engage in marital relations in the home of his host.[218] However, if the host has designated a private home [or room[219]] for the couple [which can be closed and locked to prevent others from entering,[220] and in which the Baal Habayis has no reason to enter[221]], then it is permitted for them to have relations.[222] [Certainly, if the host is not home, and the couple have been given the home for their stay, then it is permitted.[223]] Nonetheless, they may not sleep [and engage in marital relations] with the bedding [i.e. sheets, blankets] of the host [and thus they are to place their own sheets under them, or at the very least place a towel that they own under them[224]].[225] [If the host has designated two separate rooms, one for the husband and one for the wife, then it is forbidden for them to join each other in a single room and have marital relations.[226] Furthermore, some Poskim[227] rule that a designated room is only valid if it is designated permanently for the couple’s use, and not for a mere night’s lodging, and therefore even if the host is not home it would be forbidden. Practically, however, we do not rule like this opinion.[228]]
If other people are in the room:[229] If the couple have been given their own room, then they may engage in marital relations even if there is another person sleeping there, so long as he is sleeping, as is the general law. [However, some Poskim[230] are stringent in such a case and prohibit relations in a guest room that contains other people, even if the other people are sleeping.[231]]
|
Q&A May a couple have intimacy in a hotel room or Tzimmer?[232] Yes, and they may do so even using the sheets of the hotel.[233] Nonetheless, during times of room service, it is best to place a “do not disturb” sign on the door.
May a couple have intimacy in the home of their in-laws? Yes. A couple who is staying as a guest in the home of his or her parents may engage in intimacy, so long as they have their own room and use their own sheets or towels, as stated above. See next!
Living in the home of one’s in-laws:[234] The Sages prohibited a man from living in the home of his in-laws due to it being considered a brazen act.[235] Nonetheless, if the couple has been designated their own room, as stated above, it is permitted for them to live there [and be intimate].[236] Some Poskim[237] learn that the prohibition only applies if the mother in-law lives at home, due to worry of a forbidden relationship. Other Poskim,[238] however, rule the prohibition applies even in a case that the mother in-law does not live at home. Practically, the widespread custom today is to be lenient in this matter [and live in the house of one’s in-laws, even if the mother in-law is there, and to permit having intimacy while there].[239] [This discussion only applies to the home of the wife’s parents, however, to live in the home of the husband’s parents is permitted without restriction according to all. Nevertheless, intimacy would only be allowed if they have their own designated room, as stated above. However, seemingly it is not necessary for them to have their own sheets and towels if they are staying there for a while and considered part of their parents’ household.]
|
__________________________________________________
[1] See Taharas Yisrael 240:81-86
[2] Michaber 240:3 [mostly omitted from Michaber E.H. 25]; Tur 240:1 and E.H. 25:8; Ra’avad in Ba’alei Hanefesh Sha’ar Hakedusha 5 and 6; Menoras Hama’or Ner Gimel K’lal Vav 5:2; See Beis Shmuel 25:8; Chelkas Mechokeik 25:7]; Rambam Hilchos Dei’os 5:4; Nedarim 20b; See Siddur Ya’avetz Mitos Kesef 6:7; Kitzur SHU”A 150:13; Taharas Yisrael 240:22-30; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:11; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 497-535
[3] See wording in P”M 240 A”A 13
[4] Ran Nedarim 20b; Siddur Ya’avetz Mitos Kesef 6:8
[5] Sha’areiy Kedusha of Ra’avad, brought in Beis Yosef 240; Levush 240; See Beis Shmuel 25:8; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that the negative effect of the Bnei Tesha Midos is only on the children and not on the husband. [See Beis Shmuel E.H. 25:8 that so is implied from Tur; 119:1; Mishneh L’melech Issurei Biyah 21:28, brought in Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1]
[6] See Poskim in previous footnote
[7] Tur 240:2 “Even if she is not pregnant [which implies certainly if she is – See Beis Yosef on Tur 240:2]”; Ra’avad in Ba’alei Hanefesh Sha’ar Hakedusha 6; P”M 240 A”A 13; Pischeiy Teshuvah E.H. 119:1 that so applies according to Ra’avad ibid; M”B 240:21; Kaf Hachaim 240:39; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; See Biur Halacha 240:1 “Ela Be’onah” that even when pregnancy is not applicable, such as an old woman or a woman who lost her womb, one must still act with holiness because there are new souls created
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that the Bnei Tesha Midos restrictions do not apply while the woman is pregnant, as the child is already formed. [Mishneh Limelech Issurei Biyah 21:28, brought in Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1]
[8] Tur 240:2, “All these Tishe Midos apply even when the intercourse is necessary for the sake of procreation, such as that she is not pregnant, nonetheless, it blemishes the child and he is called a Posheia”; Beis Yosef on Tur ibid, “It makes no difference whether he already fulfilled the Mitzvah of Peru Urevu or not”; Bach on Tur ibid, “Meaning, even if he needs to do so to fulfill his Biblical command of Peru Urevu”; Ra’avad in Ba’alei Nefesh p. 136, brought in Beis Yosef ibid; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240 footnote 84; See Eiruvin 100b
[9] Michaber O.C. 240:3 “Anussa”; E.H. 25:2 “If she is not pleased, then one must appease her until she is satisfied”; Eiruvin 100b; Ramban in Igeres Hakodesh 6; Menoras Hama’or Ner 3 K’lal 6 6:5; Chareidim Chapter 51 “it’s a Rabbinical prohibition to have relations with one’s wife against her will.” See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 52:1-6
[10] M”B 240
[11] M”A and Poskim in next footnote; Pischeiy Olam 240:13; Taharas Yisrael 2 240:22; See Tur 240; Ba’al Haturim Devarim 5:16; P”M 240 A”A 7; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 52 footnote 2
[12] M”A 240:7; Kaf Hachaim 240:30; Reishis Chochma 16:24 based on Zohar Kedoshim, “One is required to rejoice his wife at that time,” that the husband is required to cajole her to desire him and that there should be no discord between them; Zohar Raya Mihemna Ki Seitzei p. 276; Zohar Tikkun 21; Zohar Bereishis 49b; M”B 240:14
[13] See Beir Mayim Chaim Bereishis 7 p. 32
[14] Eiruvin ibid
[15] Michaber 240:3; See Kallah Rabasi 1:16 that these children too will become rapists [See Ravaan p. 39 and Shita Mekubetzes on Nedarim ibid that this means that his sons too will rape their wives and even other women]
[16] Ba’al Haturim ibid; Tur ibid; Miseches Kallah ibid
[17] See Beir Mayim Chaim Bereishis 7 p. 32
[18] Ramban in Igeres Hakodesh 6
[19] Rambam Ishus 15:18; See Piskeiy Teshuvos 240 footnote 87
[20] Elya Raba 240:10; Bach 240; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:11
[21] See Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid which learns that it applies to all acts; Vetzaruch Iyun, as all the sources refer specifically to intercourse.
[22] Bach 240:4; Elya Raba 240:10; Atzei Arazim 25:1; Niddah 31b; Eiruvin 100b; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 551
[23] Eiruvin 100b
[24] Ezer Mikodesh E.H. 25:2
[25] See Piskeiy Teshuvos 240 footnote 85
[26] See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 52:7
[27] Perisha E.H. 77:5; Rambam Deios 4:5
[28] Rashi Niddah 17a
[29] See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 52:8
[30] Atzei Arazim 25:1
[31] Chelkas Mechokeik E.H. 25:3; Atzei Arazim 25:1
[32] Beis Shmuel E.H. 77:4; Perisha E.H. 77:5; Mili D’ezra p. 93; Tzitz Eliezer 7:34; Mishpitei Shaul 19 and Rav Elyashiv in Teshuvah 34;
[33] Rambam Dei’os 5:4-5 regarding negation of laziness and depression or being upset; Sefer Chassidim 563 regarding negation of being in a state of anger or being upset and so writes Morah B’etzba 1:11; Shevet Mussar 24; Avraham Anochi 1 Teruma 10 regarding being sad or depressed; Tikkunei Zohar Tikkun 56 regarding being upset or depressed; Many Rishonim and Sefarim emphasize the need for love, joy and passion during intimacy in order so that it has a positive effect on the child born: See Rambam ibid; Nedarim 20b and Shita Mekubetzes ibid in name of Riem and Ritva; Sefer Chassidim 362; Menoras Hama’or Ner Hashelishi 6:6 5:185; Reishis Chochmah Sha’ar Hakedusha 16; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos 6:10; Torah L’shma 72, “Regarding that which you asked, if a person who just woke up from his sleep and is completely uninterested in having intercourse to the point that he almost despises it, may do so anyways, or if he has to do things in order to arouse his desire and lust. The answer: it is not good to have intercourse without any desire and on the contrary one must have will and desire of his own. Thus, it is better for one to arouse his will and lust, in his heart, for the intercourse than for him to despise it. For this purpose, it is permitted for him to even speak words of frivolity with his wife, in order to arouse his desire. Although, one must intend to have intercourse for the sake of fulfilling God’s commandment; one must also do it with lust and desire with all of his heart”; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 497-502
[34] Rambam ibid; Shevet Hamussar ibid; Avraham Anochi ibid
[35] Lechem Mishneh Hilchos Dei’os 5:4
[36] Shevet HaMussar 24
[37] Admur Y.D. 184:41; Taz 184:1; Shach 184:31; Kallah Rabasi 1:16; Tosafos Niddah 12a; Ramban in Igeres Hakodesh 6; Elya Raba 240:9; Siddur Ya’avetz Mitos Kesef 6:7 and Chulya Gimel 7:4; P”M 240 A”A 12; Kitzur SHU”A 130:13; M”B 240:21; Kaf Hachaim 240:37; See Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:14; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 52:9-10
[38] Admur ibid; Kallah Rabasi ibid
[39] Chosen Yeshu’os 2:127
[40] Admur ibid; Taz ibid; Shach ibid; Otzer Haposkim E.H. 25:9; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid
[41] Ashel Avraham Butchach 240:10; Pela Yoeitz Zivug; Chesed Le’alafim 240:6
[42] See all Poskim in previous footnotes regarding laziness and depression; Rashi on Niddah 17a; Torah L’shma 72 at length that if one woke up after midnight for intimacy and is not really interested, he should not simply do so out of Kabalas Ol but rather needs to arouse himself to desire his wife; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 56:2
[43] Michaber 240:10; Tur 240:10; Kaf Hachaim 240:68; Taharas Yisrael 240:68; See Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:11; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 51:4
[44] Pirush HaRosh on Nedarim 20b; Tur 240 “Bnei Meriva who always fight”; Shita Mekubetzes Nedarim 20b; Levush 240:2; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos 6:7; Tikkunei Zohar Tikkun 56; Reishis Chochmah Sha’ar Hakedusha 16; Sheyikadesh Atzmo ibid footnote 5
[45] Michaber E.H. 25:1; Beis Yosef 240 in name of Ra’avad; P”M 240 A”A 23; Kaf Hachaim 240:67; Taharas Yisrael 240:68
[46] Michaber O.C. 240:3; E.H. 25:8; Nedarim 20b; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 523-528
[47] M”A 240:8; Tur 240; M”B 240:15; Kaf Hachaim 240:31; See Torah L’shma 71 that so can be gleaned from the relationship of Yaakov and Leah
How was Yaakov allowed to have relations with Leah if she was hated? As during the time of Tashmish, he loved her. Alternatively, in truth he always loved her, and it was just Leah who thought that she was hated. [P”M 240 A”A 8] Alternatively, Yaakov also loved Leah, although in comparison to Rachel she was viewed as hated. [Kaf Hachaim 240:31] See Rav Poalim 3:10
[48] Mahariy Viyaal 186
[49] Rashi Nedarim ibid; Ra’avad Ba’alei HaNefesh
[50] See Kallah Rabasi 1:16 that they will hate the Mitzvos; Ba’al Haturim Ki Seitzei 21:15
[51] Kallah Rabasi ibid; Zohar Pinchas 230a
[52] Tur 240 “Bnei Meriva who always fight”; Shita Mekubetzes Nedarim 20b; Levush 240:2; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos 6:7; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 53:2
[53] Sheyikadesh Atzmo 52 footnote 6
[54] Igeres Hateshuvah of Rabbeinu Yona Yom Shishi; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 52:5
[55] Ashel Avraham Butchach 240:3; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 56:4
[56] Implication of Michaber ibid who rules that he must appease his wife if he is angry at her; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 51:4 and 53:2
[57] Sefer Chassidim 563 regarding being in a state of anger or being upset; See also Morah B’etzba 1:11; Gilyon Aliba Dehilchasa 40:6; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 51:1
[58] See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 56:5
[59] See Torah L’shma 71 regarding one who was forced to enter a prearranged marriage despite not being attracted to her, and that so can be gleaned from the relationship of Yaakov and Leah; See also Torah L’shma 377
[60] See Maharashdam Y.D. 95
[61] Michaber 240:3; See Kaf Hachaim 240:32; See Shach Y.D. 334:12 that a Menuda is permitted in Tashmish, and only one who is in Cherem is forbidden [however, seemingly this is from the aspects of Niduiy, however due to Tishe Midos, it is forbidden even simply with Niduiy] See Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 529-534
[62] P”M 240 A”A 9; Biur Halacha 240:1 “Bnei Niduiy”
[63] P”M 240 A”A 9
[64] See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 57:3
[65] Implication of Michaber E.H. 23:2 and Rambam Issureiy Biyah 21:18 as learns Maggid Mishneh on Rambam ibid, and so learns Beis Shmuel 23:3 on Michaber ibid, and is brought in Beis Yosef E.H. 23; Niddah 13b regarding one who brings himself to an erection; Elya Raba 240:6 that with Zera Levatala the Nidduiy is automatic; Pirush Beir Hagoleh on Michaber ibid; Shulchan Hatahor 1 241:3; Kaf Hachaim 240:24;
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that even one who does Zera Levatala is not in automatic Niduiy, and is just fit to be put in Niduiy. [Opinion in Beis Yosef E.H. 23; Bach E.H. 23 in opinion of Tur; Chelkas Mechokeik 23:3; Opinions in Beis Shmuel 23:3; Perisha 240:4; Elya Raba 240:6; Tosafos Niddah 13b; Rashba; Ramban; Riy; Lechem Chamudos on Rosh Niddah 2:8 in opinion of Rambam and other Rishonim; Maggid Mishneh on Rambam Issureiy Biyah 21:18 in name of Ramban, Rabbeinu Yaakov, and Rashba]
[66] See Shulchan Hatahor 241:3; Mishneh Halachos 7 213:3 based on Riaz Moed Katan 3:2
[67] How to do Teshuvah for Zera Levatala: See Tanya chapter 7 and Igeres Hateshuvah 4 and 8
[68] Implication of Michaber Y.D. 334:43 as the 21st matter which leads to Niduiy and that if one transgresses it, “He is put into Niduiy,” which implies that until he is actually excommunicated, he is not in Niduiy; Implication of Michaber E.H. 23:2 that only one who does Zera Levatala is in automatic Niduiy [and thus the Michaber omits writing in 23:3 that one who causes himself to have erection is in Niduiy, as he is only fit to be put in Niduiy, unlike Zera Levatala]; Opinion in Beis Yosef E.H. 23; Bach E.H. 23 in opinion of Tur; Chelkas Mechokeik 23:3; Opinions in Beis Shmuel 23:3; Perisha 240:4; Elya Raba 240:6; Tosafos Niddah 13b; Rashba; Ramban; Riy; Lechem Chamudos on Rosh Niddah 2:8 in opinion of Rambam and other Rishonim; Maggid Mishneh on Rambam Issureiy Biyah 21:18 in name of Ramban, Rabbeinu Yaakov, and Rashba; Kaf Hachaim 240:24; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 57 footnote 3
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that even one who brings himself to erection is in automatic Niduiy. [Maggid Mishneh on Rambam Issureiy Biyah 21:18 that so is implied from Rambam, and so brings Beis Yosef ibid; Beis Shmuel 23:3 in implication of Michaber E.H. 23:2 regarding Zera Levatala, and the same would apply to an erection; Pirush Beir Hagoleh on Michaber ibid; Shulchan Hatahor 1 241:3; Implication of Setimas Kol Haposkim ibid]
[69] Michaber O.C. 240:2 and 3 regarding Bnei Temura and Bnei Irbuvya; E.H. 25:10; See M”A 240:6, 9, and 13 that Bnei Temura and Bnei Irbuvya are not exactly the same, as Bnei Temura refers to that he intended for one wife and it was really another wife, while Bnei Irbuvya is that he intended for the correct wife, but simply thought about the other wife or woman; So also explains M”B 240:13 in Michaber 240:2 and M”B 240:16 and 20 in Michaber 240:3; Taharas Yisrael 240:21; Kaf Hachaim 240:29, 33-34, and 38; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 515-522, 543; See Rashbam Pesachim 112a who defines thinking of another woman as Bnei Gerushas Haleiv
How was Yaakov allowed to have relations with Leah if he thought that she was Rachel? As when he saw Leah under the Chupah, he mistook Leah for Rachel [as they seemingly looked similar], and to begin with intended to be with that body. The above restriction is only if at the time of the relations one thinks of a different body of a woman and not if one is mistaken in the identity of the woman. [M”A 240:9; Sha’ar Hatziyon 240:7] Alternatively, in truth for this reason Bnei Reuvein did not receive an inheritance in Eretz Yisrael. [M”A ibid in name of Asara Ma’amaros; See Rav Poalim 3:10 who questions this assertion and gives alternative explanations] Alternatively, in truth she did not become pregnant from him on that night, due to this reason. [Elya Raba 240:6 in name of Ra’avad in Ba’alei Nefesh] Alternatively, since the Torah was yet to be given, they were not required to be careful in this. [Elya Raba ibid in name of Ra’avad ibid] Alternatively, since Leah was thinking only about Yaakov, it is not considered Bnei Temurah. [Birkeiy Yosef 240:4 in name of Koveitz Yashan] Alternatively, Yaakov was not thinking at all about anyone or any lust during the intercourse, and was rather spiritually focused on the union of the Sefiros, and hence it was not considered Bnei Temurah. [Rav Poalim 3:10] Alternatively, the reason is because Yaakov already suspected that he may be tricked by Lavan and given Leah as a wife, and hence he intended to be with whomever he indeed married in order for the child born from that union not be a Bnei Temura. [Kaf Hachaim 240:33]
How was David’s birth not a Bnei Temurah: Yishai, the father of David, had intended to be intimate with his freed maid, when in truth he was intimate with his wife. Nonetheless, this was not considered actual Bnei Temurah [See Asara Mamaros Ma’amar Chikur Hadin 3:10], as he fully intended for the woman who he was intimate with and simply mistook her identity for someone else. [M”A ibid regarding Yaakov and Leah and the same could apply here; Pachad Yitzchak Mareches Machshava Tova] Alternatively, Yishai was not thinking at all about anyone or any lust during the intercourse, and was rather spiritually focused on the union of the Sefiros, and hence it was not considered Bnei Temurah. [Rav Poalim 3:10]
[70] Michaber 240:2; E.H. 25:10; M”A 240:9; Kaf Hachaim 240:33
[71] See Nedarim 20b; Rashbam Pesachim 112a “His children are close to Mamzeirim”; Sefer Hayirah of Rabbeinu Yonah, “Don’t think of another woman as it almost makes one children Mamzeirim.”; Baal Haturim Kedoshim 19:18; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 55:2 footnote 6
[72] See Siddur Arizal of Rav Shabsi p. 42; Pokeiach Ivrim ibid that the thoughts of a woman about other men during the day can cause her to have evil thoughts at night and cause the children to be born with many character flaws.
[73] Rabbeinu Yonah Brachos 5b
[74] Midrash Tanchuma Naso 7; Rokei’ach 317; Yifei Laleiv 240:8; Sefer Chassidim 515; Kaf Hachaim 240:38; Pokeiach Ivrim [of Mittler Rebbe 9; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 55 footnote 1 and 2; See Birkeiy Yosef 240:4 in name of Koveitz Yashan who implies that in fact it is only cosndireed Bnei Temura if also the wife is thinking of another man, Vetzaruch Iyun.
[75] See Birkeiy Yosef 240:4 in name of Koveitz Yashan
[76] Emek Hamelech Sha’ar Tikkunei Teshuvah 11; Solels Belulah 240:6 in name of Emek Hamelech; Kaf Hachaim 240:34; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 55:2-3
[77] See Kaf Hachaim [Falagi] 27:9; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 55:4
[78] See Ezer Mikodesh E.H. 23:3; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 55:4
[79] See Admur, Hilchos Talmud Torah 1:13, that a man may only be a Milameid for boys if his wife is in the city, or is married at the very least, as even if he comes to be sexually aroused by one of the mothers of the boys, he has his wife available to him who can save him from sin; Levush Y.D. 157:2; Sefer Pachad Yitzchak Machshava Tova;
[80] See Kesubos 65b that Rava asked to be intimate with his wife after seeing the arms of the wife of Abayey in Beis Din
[81] Admur ibid
[82] Peri Eitz Chaim Sha’ar 16:11; Reishis Chochmah 16:16 in name of Ramak in Or Hachama 96, “One must guard that he does not become aroused and excited by foreign lusts, from Na’amah, as the Zohar states that occasionally Na’amah comes to the world to excite people, and the person is found in a state of lust with her, and he lusts for what he saw in his dream. Now, if he has a child from this union, this child will belong to Na’amah, and when Lilis comes and sees him, she connects with this child, and is with him every Rosh Chodesh and tries to hurt him.”; Or Tzadikim 27:9; Chesed Le’avraham Mayan 7 Nahar 25; Elya Raba 240:1; Beir Heiytiv 240:24 in name of Arizal; M”B 240:54; Kav HaYashar 17; Da’as Kedusha 7:40; Kaf Hachaim 240:26; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 280-282
[83] M”B ibid Reishis Chochma ibid
[84] See Chesed Le’avarahm ibid that it will either cause the children to be born with a soul from Lilis (and he will die during nursing age), or from demons, or will become a rebel of which a stillborn is even better than this.
[85] Acharei Mos 77a
[86] Chesed Le’avraham, ibid; Reishis Chochma 16:19
[87] Reishis Chochma 16:19, “Stab your nails into the ground or think about the day of death”; Pischei Olam 240:41; Kaf Hachaim 240:26; Seemingly, this causes the blood to flow to one’s fingers and drains it from one’s Eiver.
[88] See Darkei Taharah p. 212; Kedushas Habanim 1:16; Kedushas Moshe 2 footnote 100; Sheyikadesh Atzmo ibid
[89] See M”A 240:9 that Yaakov intended for Leah (and her body) even though he thought she was Rachel, and did not transgress Bnei Temurah; Levush Y.D. 157:2 and Pachad Yitzchak Ma’areches Machshava Tova that if a husband has grown passion for a married woman, his wife may trick him to make him think that she is that married woman, and that intimacy is not considered Bnei Temurah, as understood from the case of Rebbe Chiyah in Kiddushin 81b; and with Yishai the father of David. See Asara Ma’amaros Mamar Chikur Hadin 3:10
[90] See Poskim ibid
[91] See Pesachim 112a and Rashbam there regarding a divorcee, and even a widow; Iyun Yaakov on Pesachim ibid; Ben Yehoyada Pesachim ibid; Chasam Sofer E.H. 133; Teshuvos Maimaniyos Shoftim Semachos 20; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 59
[92] See Meiri Pesachim 112a
[93] Mesores Moshe p. 405
[94] Michaber 240:3; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 510-512
[95] Kitzur SHU”A 150:13; M”B 240:17
[96] M”A 240:10; P”M 240 A”A 10; M”B 240:17; Kaf Hachaim 240:35
[97] Aruch Hashulchan 240:9
[98] Levush 240:2
[99] Michaber O.C. 240:3; E.H. 25:9; Nedarim 20b; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 513-514
[100] Michaber E.H. ibid “Him or her”; M”A 240:11; Kaf Hachaim 240:36; Ra’avad in Ba’alei Hanefesh Sha’ar Hakedusha
[101] The reason: As when one of them is drunk they do not have intent for love but rather for lust. [Ra’avad ibid]
[102] P”M 240 A”A 11; M”B 240:16; Kaf Hachaim 240:36
[103] Poskim in previous footnote
[104] Moed Lekol Chaiy 31:24
[105] Rashi and Ran Nedarim ibid
[106] Sefer Zechira Zivug
[107] Michaber O.C. 240:3; E.H. 25:8; See also Michaber E.H. 119:1-2 and the Nosei Keilim there; Nedarim 20b [Bnei Teisha Midos]; Gittin 90a [Al Tacharosh]; Yevamos 37b [Marrying on condition of divorce]; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:12; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 535-542
[108] The law if he intends to divorce her in the late future: Some Poskim rule that the above prohibition only applies when one has actually started the divorce process, or is ready to do so in the very near future. If, however, one only plans to start the process in a few months or years, then there is no prohibition in being intimate. Thus, if a couple is waiting to divorce until all their kids are married, then they may have intimacy until the time for divorce has arrived. [See Beis Shmuel 119:1; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 58:7-8]
[109] M”A 240:12; Beis Shmuel 119:1 in name of Tur, Rosh, and Ba’al Haturim Parshas Va’eschanon; M”B 240:19; Kaf Hachaim 240:37; See Taz 119:1-2
[110] Michaber E.H. ibid; M”A 240:12; Beis Shmuel 119:1 in name of Tur, Rosh, and Ba’al Haturim Parshas Va’eschanon
The reason: As we apply here the verse, “Al Tacharosh Al Rei’acha Rah.” [Beis Shmuel 119:1; Chelkas Mechokeik 119:1; Tur 119] This is in addition to the fact that the offspring of such a union are included in the Bnei Teisha Midos, of which the children are destined to become rebels and heretics r”l. [See Nedarim ibid; Beis Shmuel 119:1; Get Pashut 119:3; Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1] The reason for this prohibition is because when one has decided to divorce his wife, he commonly thinks of another woman during intercourse. [Rosh Nedarim 2, brought in Mishneh L’melech Issurei Biyah 21:28, and Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1]
[111] Setimas Kol Haposkim
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that the above prohibition only applied in previous times, prior to Takanas Rabbeinu Gershon, when one was able to divorce his wife against her will. However, today, since one is no longer allowed to divorce his wife against her will, the prohibition no longer applies, as he is stuck in the marriage regardless. Hence, he may appease her and be intimate with her despite his ideal desire to divorce her. [Chochmas Shlomo 119]
[112] Possible understanding of Michaber E.H. 119:2 and so learns Beis Shmuel 119:1 and Peri Chadash 119:2 [in negation of possibility offered in Chelkas Mechokeik 119:1]; Rav Akiva Eiger 119:1 in name of K’neses Hagedola 119, in name of Ra’avad in Tamim De’im 239 that it applies even regarding living together
Other opinions: Some Poskim suggest that perhaps it is permitted for them to live together, without intimacy, even if he has already decided to divorce her. [Mishneh L’melech Issurei Biyah 21:28; Chelkas Mechokeik 119:1; See Aruch Hashulchan 119:9]
[113] See Kallah Rabasi 1:16
[114] Peri Chadash 119:2; Teshuvas Hage’onim 188; Get Pashut 119:3, brought in Mishneh L’melech Issurei Biyah 21:28, and Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1; Beir Heiytiv 25:8; 1st option in Perisha 25:31, brought in Beis Shmuel 25:9, based on Michaber E.H. 119:1; 1st option in Chelkas Mechokeik 119:1; Mishneh L’melech Issurei Biyah 21:28, brought in Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1, concludes that the prohibition does not apply in such a case, if he does not intend to marry another woman; Maharsha Gittin 90a; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:12
Other opinions: Possibly, the above prohibition applies even if one’s wife is aware of the impending divorce, as perhaps it is only permitted to have relations by a temporary marriage, in which the wife was aware of the divorce before the wedding. [2nd option in Perisha ibid, Beis Shmuel ibid and Chelkas Mechokeik ibid; See Mishneh L’melech Issurei Biyah 21:28, brought in Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1]
[115] The reason: As it is permitted to marry a woman on a temporary basis, if she has been informed. [Poskim ibid]
[116] Seeming conclusion of Beis Shmuel 25:9; 119:1; Chelkas Mechokeik 119:1; Perisha 25:31 [as understands Beis Shmuel 119:1]; Mishneh L’melech Issurei Biyah 21:28, brought in Pischeiy Teshuvah 119:1, applies the prohibition if he intends to marry another woman; Get Mekushar p. 3a; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 58:5; See Toras Menachem 5745 4:2379
[117] Mishneh L’melech ibid; Get Mekushar ibid; Toras Menachem 5745 4:2379
Explanation: Having intercourse with one’s wife when one intends on divorcing her touches on two Halachic issues: 1) “Al Tacharosh Al Rei’acha Rah.” And 2) Bnei Gerushas Haleiv. Although in this case the first issue may be irrelevant, nonetheless, the prohibition of Bnei Gerushas Haleiv is still applicable. The previous Poskim, however, argue on this point as well. See Get Pashut ibid; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 58:5 footnote 9
[118] Peri Chadash 119:2; Rav Akiva Eiger 119:1 in name of K’neses Hagedola 119, in name of Ra’avad in Tamim Deim 239
[119] See Taz 119:2 that if he has the Halachic right to divorce her, then we apply the prohibition of the verse, “Al Tacharosh,” however, if one does not have the Halachic right to divorce her, then it can be understood from the Taz ibid that they may live together and be intimate [if he does not hate her at the time of intimacy] as his deliberations are merely theoretical in nature. See also Aruch Hashulchan O.C. 240:9 that it is only considered Bnei Gerusha if he has decided to divorce her, and E.H. 119:9, that if he does not intend to divorce her at the time of intercourse, but rather at a later date, then there is no prohibition. See also Chochmas Shlomo ibid for a similar allowance to continue intimacy if she has the right to not agree to the divorce; Taharas Yisrael 240:28; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:12
[120] Get Pashut E.H. 119:3; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 58:7
[121] See Beis Shmuel 119:1; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 58:7-8
[122] See Shabbos 56a; Geresh Carmel Revid Hazahav 5 Va’eschanon p. 15; Mesores Moshe p. 505; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 58:8
[123] Mesores Moshe p. 508
[124] Michaber 240:3 “Bnei Chatzufa,” as explained in M”A 240:14; Tur 240; Rambam Ishus 15:18; Kallah Rabasi 1; Kitzur SHU”A 150:8; Kaf Hachaim 240:39; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:13; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 148-156; See Eiruvin 100b; Kesubis 65a
[125] Tur 240; Mili Dechassidusa 517; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 6:3
[126] Rashi Nedarim 20b; Ran Nedarim ibid; Perisha 240:7; Elya Raba 240:9; Chochmas Adam 128:19; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 6:4 footnote 8
Examples: She may say “come to me” as Leah said to Yaakov, or any other term so long as the act of intercourse is not explicitly mentioned. [Perisha ibid]
[127] Yifei Laleiv 5 240:7; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 6:4
[128] Beir Moshe 1:49-2
[129] M”A ibid; Beiry Heiytiv 240:14; Aruch Hashulchan E.H. 25; M”B 240:21; Taharas Yisrael 240:29; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; See Avraham Min Hahar Nedarim 20b, “If she verbally asks for it in a brazen strong and light headed manner”; Shita Mekubetzes Nedarim ibid
[130] Kallah Rabasi ibid and Pirush Ravan Hayarchi
[131] See Perisha 240:7; Elya Raba 240:9; Beir Moshe3 1:49-2; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 6:4 footnote 8
[132] Sefer Chassidim 516; Elya Raba 240:9; Taharas Yisrael 240:30; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 6:5
[133] See Beis Yisrael 26; Beir Moshe 1:49-3; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 6 footnote 3
[134] Michaber 240:15; Tur 240:15 and E.H. 25:2; Rambam Dei’os 5:4; Igeres Hakodesh of the Ramban Chapter 3; See Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 4:1-2 part 2 and 7:2; Taharas Yisrael 240:82; Kaf Hachaim 240:88; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:27; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 377
[135] Kitzur SHU”A 150:15; See coming footnotes
[136] The reason: One is not to have intercourse when hungry, as this can cause the child to be weak and dull headed. Likewise, one is not to have intercourse when one is satiated after eating, doing so can cause the child to be Megusham, as the seed will derive from the waste products of the food and will cause the child to have difficulty in comprehension and a stone heart. [Kesef Mishneh Dei’os 5:4; Igeres Hakodesh of Ramban 1-3; Chesed Le’avraham Mayan 4:11; Elya Raba 240:22; Pela Yoeitz Zivug; Siddur Ya’avetz ibid and 4:3 that if the seed is too warm from the food then the child will have an angry temperament, and if from cold seed due to hunger, he will be stupid; Kaf Hachaim 240:88; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 33 footnote 1] It can also cause the child to have very bad character traits such as anger. [Ramban ibid] Likewise, it is unhealthy for the person to have intercourse when hungry or satiated after a meal, independent of the possible effects on the child. [Kesef Mishneh ibid; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid]
[137] Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos 7 1:2; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 33:2
[138] Pela Yoeitz Zivug; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 33:1 footnote 1; However, from the Kesef Mishneh, and Poskim ibid, it can be implied that this adherence applies mainly to the husband and not the wife.
[139] See Kesef Mishneh ibid in previous footnote; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 33:1 and 3
[140] Igeres Hakodesh of Ramban Chapters 3 and 4; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 5:1
[141] Ramban ibid; Siddur Ya’avetz ibid
[142] M”A 240:29; Seder Hayom p. 2 in name of Zohar; Gittin 70a, “One who leaves a bathroom is not to have relations.; Menoras Hama’or Ner Gimel K’lal Vav 5:3; See Kaf Hachaim 240:27; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:28; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 379-382; Vetzaruch Iyun if this adherence is viewed as an actual obligation, or a voluntary, or encouraged adherence due to Sakana.
[143] The reason: This is due to the bathroom demon that escorts the person when he leaves the bathroom and blemishes the intimacy, causing the child to be physically defected. [Gittin ibid; Seder Hayom ibid in name of Zohar; Beir Heiytiv ibid; Yad Ephraim 240; Sefer Zechira Zivug that the demon can cause the wife to become baron]
[144] Setimas Kol Haposkim ibid who do not mention the damage of the child as a reason for the restriction, and make no mention that it only applies to intimacy which can lead to pregnancy; See previous footnote that although the main reason is due to damage to the children, nonetheless, in truth, even if pregnancy is not an issue, it should still be avoided due to the “blemish of the intimacy” that the demon can cause, irrelevant of pregnancy.
[145] Beir Moshe 5:1; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid
[146] Darkei Chayim Veshalom 346; Beir Moshe 5:1; Shraga Hameir 4:84; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 34:2; See Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid that perhaps one may be lenient with today’s bathrooms that also contain a shower and the like.
So rule regarding the requirement to wash hands after using a bathroom, that it applies even if one did not actually use it: See Peri Megadim 227 A.A. 2; M”B 4:40 in name of Artzos Hachaim and other Teshuvos; Ketzos Hashulchan 2 footnote 29; Chida in Bris Olam 8:23; Kesem Paz on Zohar; Kaf Hachaim [Falagi] 8:18; Amudei Hashulchan 2:14; Ben Ish Chaiy Toldos 16; Soles Belula 7:1; brought in Kaf Hachaim 4:65
The reason: Upon entering a bathroom, the spirit of impurity resides, irrelevant of whether he used it to relieve himself. [Chida in Bris Olam 8:23; Kesem Paz on Zohar; Soles Belula ibid; Kaf Hachaim ibid]
[147] M”A ibid “Beis Hakisei Kavua”; Seder Hayom ibid; Elya Raba 240:1; K’neses Hagedola 240; M”B 240:54; Kaf Hachaim ibid; Beir Moshe ibid; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid
Other opinions: Some are stringent even in such a case. [Darkei Chaim Veshalom ibid]
[148] Seder Hayom ibid in name of Zohar in unknown source]; Beir Heiytiv 240:24; Elya Raba 240:1; Olas Tamid 240:7; Or Tzadikim 27:10; Aruch Hashulchan 240:18; Kitzur SHU”A 150:16; Opinion in M”B 240:54 and Taharas Yisrael 240:20; See Yad Ephraim 240 that it does not refer to a literal hour of 60 minutes but rather to that session, and thus even after two Mil [36-48 minutes] it is permitted; See Kitzur Sh’lah Inyanei Zivug which writes that the Shiur is 30 minutes; See Gittin ibid and Poskim in next footnote who seemingly argue and rule that the Shiur is half a Mil, which is 9-12 minutes.
[149] Gittin ibid; Birkeiy Yosef 240:12; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 7 Chulya Beis 5; Shulchan Hatahor 240:11; M”B 240:54 in name of Yad Efraim ibid; Misgeres Hashulchan 150:12; Kaf Hachaim 240:27; Divrei Yatziv 1:104; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; See Menoras Hama’or Ner 6 K’lal 1 1:1 that one is to wait a full Shiur Mil
[150] How much is a Mil? Some Poskim rule that a Mil is 18 minutes [1st opinion in Admur 459:10; Michaber ibid and in Yoreh Deah 69:6; Rama 261:1; Maryu 193; Terumos Hadeshen 123], and hence the total time to wait after using the bathroom is 9 minutes. [Misgeres Hashulchan 150:16] Other Poskim rule that a Mil is 24 minutes [2nd opinion in Admur 459:10; Rambam in Pirush Hamishnayos Pesachim 3:2], and hence the total time to wait after using the bathroom is 12 minutes. [Shulchan Hatahor 240:11; Taharas Yisrael 240:20; Misgeres Hashulchan 150:16 concludes to wait 9 and at best 112 minutes] Practically, Admur mainly rules like the opinion of 24 minutes. [Admur ibid; See Ketzos Hashulchan 3 Seder Hachnasas Shabbos 5]
[151] Sheyikadesh Atzmo 34:2
[152] So rule regarding the requirement to wash hands in such a case: Kaf Hachaim 3:3 and 4:66; Mishneh Yosef 5:6; Torah Leshma 23; Lev Chaim 4:2; Ruach Chaim 3:3; Yabia Omer 9:108
[153] So rule regarding the requirement to wash hands in such a case: Lehoros Nasan 7:1; Tzitz Eliezer 7:2; Piskeiy Teshuvos 4:20 footnote 200; See Da’as Torah 4
[154] Michaber 240:15; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 7:2; See Ateres Zekeinim that perhaps this applies likewise to the day before and the day after; See Taharas Yisrael
[155] Makor Chaim of Chavos Yair 240; Aruch Hashulchan E.H. 25:3; See Upikadeta Navecha p. 51
[156] Siddur Ya’avetz, laws of Erev Shabbos, rules that one is to bathe his hands, feet and face in hot water; Kitzur SH”A 72 rules that one is not to bathe his entire body in hot water
[157] M”A 240:29; Elya Raba 240:23; M”B 240:54
[158] Elya Raba 240:23; Bach E.H. 25; Perisha E.H. 25; K’neses Hagedola 240
[159] Taharas Yisrael
[160] Setimas Kol Haposkim in 260: See Admur 260:1; Rama 260:1; Gemara Shabbos 25b
Ruling of Ya’avetz – Not to enter entire body into hot water: The Ya’avetz in his Siddur rules that one is to bathe his hands, feet and face in hot water. One is not, however, to enter into a bathhouse as doing so can cause difficulty in marital relations, which is supposed to be performed on Friday night, as is written in the laws of Derech Eretz. Practically, Admur does not mention this ruling of the Ya’avetz, despite him mentioning other matters [i.e. eating garlic] which are to be done to enhance Tashmish, and we thus see that he does not suspect for this at all. Therefore, it remains a Mitzvah upon all to bathe their entire body in hot water on Erev Shabbos as rules Admur. Furthermore, even according to the Ya’avetz, if one’s wife is not pure, one is to bathe his entire body in hot water. Furthermore, even when she is pure, it is likely that the Ya’avetz was referring to the bathhouses of the past which consisted of an entire lengthy bathing ritual of sauna, steam room and hot tub. Thus, mere showering in hot water was not being referred to, and hence remains a Mitzvah upon all to perform. To note, however, from Kitzur SH”A 72 which states that the Ya’avetz rules that one is not to bathe his entire body in hot water, without mentioning the idea of a bathhouse, as is the original words of the Ya’avetz.
[161] Makor Chaim of Chavos Yair 240; Aruch Hashulchan E.H. 25:3; See Upikadeta Navecha p. 51
[162] Michaber 240:15; Tur O.C. 240:15 and E.H. 25:2; Admur Hilchos Shemiras Haguf V’Nefesh 5; Gittin 70a; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 2:2
[163] Admur ibid; Gittin ibid
[164] Darkei Taharah p. 212; Upikadeta Navecha 4:38; Sheyikadesh Atzmo ibid
[165] Tzeida Laderech; Elya Raba 240:22; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos 7 Chulya 2; M”B 240:53; Kaf Hachaim 240:89; Darkei Taharah p. 212; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 2:1
[166] Tur 240; Rambam Dei’os 4:19
[167] M”A 240:29
[168] See Mikdash Melech on Zohar Vayikra 43a
[169] See Kaf Hachaim 240:56
[170] M”A 564:1 in name of Sh’lah; Or HaYashar p. 20a
[171] See Kaf Hachaim ibid
[172] Michaber O.C. 240:6; E.H. 25:2, “One may not have relations in front of any human species, even a child, unless the child does not know how to talk”; Tur 240:6; Niddah 17b; See Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 7 Chulya 3:7; Kitzur SHU”A 150:4; Taharas Yisrael 240:41-43; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:16; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 311-316
[173] Chelkas Mechokeik 25:3; Beis Shmuel 25:4
[174] Elya Raba 240:13; Kaf Hachaim 240:43
[175] Elya Raba 240:13; Olas Tamid 240:3; See Kaf Hachaim 240:42
[176] Michaber O.C. ibid; Tur 240; Taz 25:1; Beis Shmuel 25:4; Siddur Ya’avetz ibid
[177] The reason: As the person can tell what they are doing and it is therefore not Tznius. [Taz ibid; M”B 240:22]
[178] Implication of Elya Raba 240:13; Olas Tamid 240:3; See Kaf Hachaim 240:42
[179] Taz E.H. 25:1; Chochmas Adam 128:5, brought in Kaf Hachaim ibid; M”B 240:22; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 24:2; that a Mechitza helps if the person is unaware of their intimacy
[180] Taz ibid
[181] Shiureiy Torah 3:29
Should one follow Tefach Sochakos in this regard which would make it 82 cm? See Shiureiy Torah p. 249 that an Ama Sochekes is 49 cm., and accordingly a Tefach Sochakos is 8.17 cm [i.e. 1/48 of a cm times 8.] and by the Shiur Sukkah of 7×7 one should measure with an Ama Sochakos, Vetzaruch Iyun if the same would apply here Lechumra even though it is only Rabbinical. If so, then its exact Shiur is 81.7 cm; See also M”B 633:2 and Sha’ar Hatziyon 633:2 that by Sukkah we follow the stringent approach in the dimensions, either Dochakos or Sochakos, and by the 7×7 dimension we follow Sochakos, and the same would apply here by the ten Tefachim dimension; See also Midos Vishureiy Torah pp. 48-57 regarding Ama Sochakos and Dochakos and when it applies; Piskeiy Teshuvos 633:1; Minchas Chinuch Mitzvah 325 who rules that by Tefachim we don’t apply the extra Dochakos or Sochakos, and this is only done by Amos.
Other opinions – Chazon Ish: According to the Chazon Ish, the measurement is 98.2 cm following the 9.82 measurement of Tefach Sochakos. [See Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid]
[182] P”M 315 A”A 3; Chayeh Adam 3:17; SSH”K 24:34
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that the Mechitza is required to be four Amos wide [i.e. 196 centimeters]. [Kaf Hachaim 240:44]
The law when using already established furniture as a Mechitza: The above minimum width is only when one intentionally sets up a Mechitza in the room for the sake of permitting Tashmish. If, however, one desires to use an already established Mechitza, such as a piece of furniture, then it is only valid if it goes from wall to wall. [See Admur 87:4]
[183] Admur 315:3
[184] Sheyikadesh Atzmo 24:2
[185] Admur 315:3 and 5; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 24:6
[186] Beis Shmuel 25:4; Elya Raba 240:13; Olas Tamid 240:3; Siddur Ya’avetz; Chochmas Adam 128:5; Kaf Hachaim 240:42
[187] Implication of Beis Shmuel 25:4 who bases the allowance of sleeping on Taz 25:1 that a Mechitza helps if the person is unaware of their intimacy
[188] Biur Halacha 240:13 “Nei’ur”
[189] Michaber ibid; Tur 240 in name of Ra’avad; Siddur Ya’avetz ibid
[190] Aruch Hashulchan 240:11
[191] See Aruch Hashulchan ibid
[192] The reason: As a child who does not yet know how to talk is considered like an animal. [Kaf Hachaim 240:43]
[193] Elya Raba 240:13; Olas Tamid 240:3; Kaf Hachaim 240:42
[194] Elya Raba 240:13 and 24 based on all sources recorded next regarding Midas Chassidus to not do so even in front of flies, and based on Zohar Vayikra which implies as such; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid
[195] Ashel Avraham Butchach Tinyana 240:6; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 24:5
[196] Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 24:5
[197] Elya Raba 240:13; Olas Tamid 240:3; Kaf Hachaim 240:42
[198] Salmas Chaim 231 or Hilchos Tzenius 109; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:16 footnote 103 that the prohibition only applies when people will be aware of the intercourse exactly when it is taking place, and not simply that they are aware that it will take place sometime; So is evident from all Yichud rooms which are fit for Biyah; See Niddah 17a that according to Rashi, Raba Bar Rav Huna would shake the bells of his canopy prior to intercourse so his family members can distance themselves, and see Tosafos there who questions this as being not Tzenius; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 22:5 footnote 5
[199] Tur 240:6 and E.H. 25:2; Elya Raba 240:13; Olas Tamid 240:3; Kaf Hachaim 240:42; Rebbe Shimon Bar Yochai in Niddah 16b, “There are four things that G-d hates and I dislike… one who has intercourse before a creature.”; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 7 Chulya 3:7; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmanson-2015] p. 321-324
[200] Tur ibid; Shmuel in Niddah ibid
[201] Niddah 17a
[202] See Rav Yehuda in Niddah ibid
[203] Tzava’as Harivash 101; See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 26 footnote 2 at length
[204] Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef Chulya Gimel 7:18
[205] Michaber 240:16; Tur 240:16; Pesachim 112b; Menoras Hama’or Ner Gimel K’lal Vav 5:3; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 7 Chulya 3:7; Kitzur SHU”A 150:16; Taharas Yisrael 240:87; Kaf Hachaim 240:92; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 311-316
[206] Olas Tamid 240:7 based on Zohar Parshas Vayikra p. 119a that it applies even if the child is asleep, and certainly if he is awake; See Kaf Hachaim ibid who concludes that perhaps this matter of the Zohar is only Midas Chassidus; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 24:7 concludes to be stringent like this opinion;
Other opinions: See Miseches Kallah 1 that it applies specifically if the child is awake, and not when he is asleep.
[207] Elya Raba 240:24 in name of Aguddah on Pesachim ibid; See Kaf Hachaim ibid
[208] Michaber ibid; Pesachim ibid
[209] Michaber ibid; Pesachim ibid, “If he is by the head of the bed, it is permitted”
[210] Olas Tamid ibid
[211] Olas Tamid ibid based on Zohar Parshas Vayikra p. 119a; See Kaf Hachaim ibid which concludes that perhaps this matter of the Zohar is only Midas Chassidus
[212] Michaber ibid, “If he is one year old”; Pesachim ibid, “If he is one year old, it is permitted”
[213] Kav Hayashar 17:5
[214] Michaber ibid; Pesachim ibid
[215] M”A 240:29; Zohar Parshas Vayikra p. 119a; Bedek Habayis in name of Zohar ibid; Kitzur SHU”A 150:16; M”B 240:54; Kaf Hachaim 240:91; Taharas Yisrael 240:87-88; Piskeiy Teshuvos 240:29; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] p. 317
[216] Vaya’an Yosef 78; Divrei Yatziv 1:104; Piskeiy Teshuvos ibid; See Beir Heiytiv and other Achronim in 240 who omitted this part of the Zohar, even though they recorded the later ruling regarding nursing after intercourse; See also Sheyikadesh Atzmo 25:1 that if she has a bottle prepared for the child then they may have intercourse even if the child is awake.
[217] Michaber O.C. 240:13; E.H. 25:7, “A guest is to avoid intercourse until he returns home”; Tur 240:13; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 7 Chulya 3:9; Kitzur SHU”A 150:14; See Rambam Issurei Biyah 21:15; Ra’avad in Ba’alei HaNefesh Sha’ar Haperisha p. 23; Kaf Hachaim 240:86-87; Sheyikadesh Atzmo [Nachmonson-2015] pp. 307-310
The novelty of this ruling: It is unclear as to what the novelty is of this prohibition, as if there are other people around in the room, it is always forbidden to have relations, even in one’s own home, and if there is no one else around then there is no reason to prohibit it. [M”A 240:27] Some, however, suggest that the novelty of this prohibition is that when one is a guest in a home, the prohibition of intimacy applies if the other people are in the room, even if they are sleeping, as opposed to in one’s own home, that intimacy is permitted in such a case if other people in the room are sleeping. [Elya Raba 240:21] However, other Poskim negate this novelty, as in truth there is no reason to differentiate. [M”A ibid; See Aruch Hashulchan 240:17] However, some write that the novelty is that the guest room must be able to be closed and locked, as perhaps the host will send another person to sleep there as well, as opposed to in one’s own home, that it is not necessary to lock the door. [Aruch Hashulchan 240:17]
[218] Michaber ibid and ibid; Tur 240:13 and E.H. 25:3, “Until he returns home”; Rambam Issurei Biyah 21:15; Kesubos 65a
The reason: As it is immodest for people to be aware that they will be engaging in intimacy. [Levush 240; Taharas Yisrael 240 footnote 359]
[219] 1st explanation in M”A 240:27, as explained in Girsa of P”M 240 A”A 27; Elya Raba 240:21; Beis Shmuel E.H. 25:7; Nehar Shalom 240:7 in name of Ra’avad; Toras Chaim Sofer 240:15; Ya’avetz; Chochmas Adam; Taharas Yisrael 240:78; M”B 240:51; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 23:1
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that a couple may not engage in marital relations unless they have been designated their own home, and having their own room within the home does not suffice. [2nd Pirush in M”A ibid]
[220] Aruch Hashulchan 240:17 in answer of question of M”A ibid; Taharas Yisrael 240:78; Toras Chaim Sofer ibid
[221] M”B 240:50
[222] Michaber ibid; Ra’avad on Rambam ibid and in Ba’alei HaNefesh Sha’ar Haperisha p. 23
[223] See Sheyikadesh Atzmo 23:1
[224] Sheyikadesh Atzmo 23:2
[225] Michaber O.C. ibid [omitted from E.H. ibid]; Ra’avad in Ba’alei HaNefesh Sha’ar Haperisha p. 23; Yuma 18b; Perisha 240:22; Taz E.H. 25:3; Chelkas Mechokeik 25:6; Beis Shmuel 25:7
The reason: As they may get semen onto the bedding, which is repulsive. [M”A 240:28; Rashi Yuma ibid; Hagahos Rav Akiva Eiger 240; Apei Zutri E.H. 25:19; M”B 240:52; Kaf Hachaim 240:87] Likewise, they never got such permission from the host. [Aruch Hashulchan 240:17]
[226] 1st explanation in M”A 240:27; Siddur Ya’avetz Mosach Hashabbos Mitos Kesef 7 Chulya 3:9
The reason: As the other household members will be aware that they are having intimacy. [M”A ibid]
[227] Mateh Yehuda 240:1; Kaf Hachaim 240:86
[228] Apei Zutri E.H. 25:9
[229] M”A 240:27; See Aruch Hashulchan 240:17
[230] Elya Raba 240:21; Taharas Yisrael 240:78; M”B 240:49; See Aruch Hashulchan 240:17
[231] The reason: As they may wake up and catch them in the middle of the act. [Taharas Yisrael 240 footnote 360]
[232] See Mateh Yehuda ibid that having a permanent designated area is like it was rented, and thus, based on this, certainly if it’s rented it is permitted; Sheyikadesh Atzmo 23:3
[233] The reason: As since they have rented the room, it is considered as if it is theirs for the night, and the owner has no permission to walk in without notice.
[234] See S’dei Chemed Mareches Ches Kelal 141; Shevet Halevi 4:166
[235] Rambam Issurei Biyah 21:15; Kiddushin 12b, “Rav would give lashes to a man who lived in his in-laws home”; Bava Basra 98b; Bei Yosef E.H. 26:4; Kitzur SHU”A 152:12
The reason: As a) One may come to sin with his mother in-law. [Rashi Pesachim 113, brought in Tosafos Riy Hazakein Kiddushin ibid] or b) As its not Tzenius, just as one should not bathe with his father in-law.
Other opinions: Some Poskim rule that this is not a true prohibition, but rather a matter of Derech Eretz. [Neharda in Kiddushin ibid; Tosafos Kiddushin ibid; Rosh Kiddushin 18; See Beis Yosef ibid] Some Poskim rule that this prohibition only refers to a Chasan who is engaged to be married, and is not yet married. [Tosafos Riy Hazakein Kiddushin ibid; China Vechisda 2 p. 220]
[236] Ra’avad on Rambam ibid; Kitzur SHU”A ibid
[237] Rashi Pesachim 113
[238] Tosafos Riy Hazakein Kiddushin 12b
[239] Tosafos Kiddushin ibid; Rosh Kiddushin 18; Meiri; Shevet Halevi ibid; See Beis Yosef ibid [this law is omitted from the Shulchan Aruch]; See Bava Kama 112a that Rav Yirmiyah lived with his in-laws
The reason: a) It is done for Tovas Hana’ah and due to lack of living space, b) there is really no prohibition to begin with, as it’s merely a matter of Derech Eretz, c) as we hold that the prohibition only applies prior to the wedding, or d) the prohibition only applied in previous generations, however, today Benos Yisrael are more careful. [See Poskim ibid; Shevet Halevi ibid]