Question:
Can a husband who desires to give a Get to his wife who is overseas appoint a Shliach to arrange the Get on his behalf [i.e. Sofer, Eidim, a Shliach Holacha], via telephone or must he appoint them in person, face to face?
Answer:
This matter is debated amongst the Poskim based on the question of whether it is necessary for the person’s actual physical voice to be heard to have a valid power of attorney for Gittin, which is not fulfilled through telephone. This debate applies to appointing both the person to arrange the Get, the Sofer, the Eidim, and Shliach Hovah or Holcha. The position of the Rebbe is that it is invalid. [However, a woman may appoint a Shliach Kabalah to receive her Get.]
See Encyclopedia Talmudit Vol. 18 p. 757 Nispach Lierech Chashmal; Beis Yitzchak E.H. 2:12-13; 53; Chazon Ish E.H. 85; Shearim Hametzuyanim Behalacha Shabbos 77:4; Beir Moshe 7 Kuntrus Elektri 33; Mishneh Halachos 14:113; Chashmal Behalacha 1:210 Chapter 17; Techumin 14:276; Yashiv Yitzchak 44:86; Minchas Asher 2:96 Poskim who rule valid: Aruch Hashulchan E.H. 140:18 [regarding Sheliach Kabalah]; Shaareiy Deiah 1:194; Maharshag 2:250; Yam Hagadol E.H. 82; Minchas Shlomo 66; Igros Moshe E.H. 1:116; O.C. 100; 4:91-4; Rav Elimelech Shechter in Koveitz Kevod Harebbe p. 268, and in name of Rav Moshe Feinstein and Rav Y.B. Soloveichik; Yabia Omer 10 E.H. 18; Beis Avi 1:125; Poskim in Encyclopedia ibid footnote 87; Invalid: Tzitz Eliezer 10:47; 22:72; Rebbe in Igros Kodesh 23:304; 34:333; Likkutei Sichos 9:336; 21:496;
Question:
Can a Get be sent to a woman via email?
Answer:
No. It is not possible for a Get to be valid via email [even if she prints it] due to several reasons [i.e. not Lishma, Not Kesiva, not Nesina] and it is Biblically invalid, and the wife remains Kosher Lekehuna]. In the event that the wife is in a different location than the husband and is unable to travel to the husband to receive the Get, then the Get is mailed [with registered mail] to the local Beis Din in her location, which then arranges for the Get to be given to her with kosher witnesses in a location designated by the Beis Din.
Sources: Yashiv Yitzchak 16:19; 44:85-86; See a dispute regarding the status of validity of a printed Get: Shut Rameh 93 [valid]; Get Pashut 125:15 [invalid]; Peri Chadash E.H. 125 [valid]; Chelkas YaakovE.H. 105 [invalid even Bemakom Igun]; Rokeiach Pesach 280; Michaber E.H. 119; Taz Y.D. 271:8; See regarding Pesul Lekehuna and if may return to husband if he is a Kohen: Michaber E.H. 150
Other Articles
Should One Add Water to the Oil Candles on Chanukah? (From the Rav’s Desk: Monday, 18th Kisleiv)
Post Views: 23 Should one Add Water to the Oil Candles of the Chanukah Menorah? Question: I grew up with the tradition of placing water in the oil candles of the Chanukah Menorah before lighting them. Is this something I am required to do? Is it proper to place water
🪦🕎 Visiting the Kever of a loved one During Chanukah (From the Rav’s Desk: Sunday, 17th Kisleiv)
Post Views: 25 Visiting the Kever of a loved one During Chanukah Question: May I visit the kever of my father during Chanukah if the Yahrzeit falls then? Answer: Generally, one should not visit a cemetery during Chanukah, even for a Yahrzeit, Shiva, or Shloshim. Instead, the visit should be
From the Rav’s Desk Thursday 14th Kisleiv: Adding Perfume or Cologne to One’s Clothing on Shabbos
Post Views: 33 Adding Perfume or Cologne to One’s Clothing on Shabbos Question: I know that one is not allowed to apply perfume or cologne to the skin or clothing on Shabbos. However, I was taught that it is permitted to refresh the same scent on one’s skin if it
From the Rav’s Desk Wednesday 13th Kisleiv: May One Who Is Not Circumcised Receive an Aliyah?
Post Views: 32 May One Who Is Not Circumcised Receive an Aliyah? Question: Rabbi, I was raised in a secular home in Russia and have not yet undergone a Bris Milah for personal reasons—not because I oppose the mitzvah, but due to circumstances beyond my control. I deeply respect the
From the Rav’s Desk Tuesday 12th Kisleiv: Chassidishe Gneiva Versus Self Centeredness: Taking the only Nagle vassar cup available to set up next to your bed
Post Views: 28 Chassidishe Gneiva Versus Self Centeredness: Taking the only Nagle vassar cup available to set up next to your bed Question During our stay at an Airbnb, our group—including both immediate and extended family and friends—had access to only one Neigle Vassar cup for ritual washing after waking
From the Rav’s Desk Monday 11th Kisleiv: Are Gerim Permitted to Hug, Kiss, and have Yichud with Their Gentile Parents of the Opposite Gender?
Post Views: 45 Are Converts Permitted to Hug, Kiss, and Be Alone with Their Gentile Parents of the Opposite Gender? Question: I recently converted to Judaism, and I have a question about my relationship with my parents who are not Jewish. Am I allowed to hug and kiss my
Leave A Comment?
You must be logged in to post a comment.