The position in which the bedtime Shema and Hamapil is to be recited

Author: Rabbi Yaakov GoldsteinPublished: February 27, 2020

The position in which the bedtime Shema and Hamapil is to be recited: If one is fulfilling his Mitzvah of the nighttime Shema with this recital: Kerias Shema may be recited while sitting, standing or lying on one’s side. One may not recite Kerias Shema while lying flat on his

The position in which the bedtime Shema and Hamapil is to be recited:

If one is fulfilling his Mitzvah of the nighttime Shema with this recital: Kerias Shema may be recited while sitting, standing or lying on one’s side. One may not recite Kerias Shema while lying flat on his back or front.[1] This applies even if one tilts slightly onto his side, until he is resting completely on his side.[2]

If one already said Shema after nightfall [in Maariv] or a woman: Some Poskim[3] rule that the above law only applies to a person who is currently fulfilling his obligation of the nighttime Shema with the bedtime Shema [such as one who Davened Maariv before nightfall[4]]. If, however, one already fulfilled his obligation of the nighttime Shema [such as he Davened Maariv after nightfall, or a woman who is not obligated in the nighttime Shema], and is simply reading it for the sake of protection, then it is permitted to be read in any position that one desires. However, other Poskim[5] conclude that nevertheless, initially, one is to recite it in a sitting position, with great concentration. Practically, according to Kabbalah it is to be read in a standing position[6], and so is the custom of Chassidim.[7]]

_________________________________________________________

[1] Michaber 63:1; Rama 239:1 “See chapter 63 regarding if it may be said in a lying position”

The reason: As in Shema one accepts the yoke of heaven, and doing so while lying is

[2] Admur 63:1

[3] M”A 239:5 based on Reb Zeira; M”B 239:6

[4] M”B ibid

[5] Chayeh Adam; P”M 239 A”A 5 question ruling of M”A ibid; M”B ibid; Kaf Hachaim 239:11

[6] Sefer Hakavanos Derush Halayla 5, brought in Beir Heiytiv 239:4; Mishnas Chassidim Miseches Hashechiva 2:1

[7] Rav Ginzberg in Seder Kerias Shema Sheal Hamita p. 6

    Loading…